Direct indexing is a way of investing in which a person owns the individual shares that make up a market index, held in a separate account in the investor's own name, instead of buying a fund that holds them. The account is managed, usually by software, to follow the index closely. Because the investor owns each share directly, the holdings can be adjusted to the investor's tax position and preferences in ways a pooled fund cannot offer.
The approach is a form of passive management and competes with the index mutual fund and with exchange-traded funds. It was long confined to wealthy clients of specialist managers. Commission-free trading, the ability to buy a fractional share and cheaper portfolio software have since brought the minimum account size down, and large fund managers and brokers bought several specialist providers around 2020 and 2021.
How it works
The investor chooses a benchmark, such as the S&P 500 or a broader stock market index, and any restrictions. The manager buys either every share in the index or, more often, a sample of a few hundred chosen by portfolio optimization to behave like the whole. The software then monitors the account, trading when cash is added, when the index changes, when a holding drifts too far from its target, or when a tax opportunity arises.
How closely the account follows the benchmark is measured by tracking error. A sampled and customized account will not match the index return exactly in any year, and may be ahead or behind.
Tax-loss harvesting
The main financial argument is tax. In a typical year some shares in an index fall even when the index as a whole rises. A fund investor cannot use those individual losses, but a direct indexing account can sell the losing positions, realize a capital loss, and buy similar shares so that the portfolio still tracks the benchmark. The realized loss can be set against gains elsewhere:
If an account realizes 10,000 dollars of losses in a year and the investor uses them against gains taxed at 20 percent, the tax bill falls by dollars. The rate is illustrative, since rates differ by country, income and holding period.
The saving is largely a deferral. The replacement shares have a lower cost basis, so a larger capital gain arises when they are eventually sold. The investor benefits from the use of the money in the meantime, and the gain may never be taxed if the shares are given to charity or, under United States rules, held until death. In the United States the wash-sale rule disallows a loss if substantially identical shares are bought within 30 days before or after the sale, which is why the software buys similar, not identical, replacements.
Customization
- Exclusions. Particular companies or industries can be left out on ethical grounds, a personal form of exclusionary screening.
- Existing holdings. An investor with a large position in one company, such as an employer, can build the rest of the index around it and reduce the concentration gradually.
- Tilts. The account can lean toward characteristics such as value or low volatility, as in factor investing.
- Transition. Shares already owned can be moved into the account without being sold, avoiding an immediate tax charge.
Costs and limitations
- Fees. The management fee is usually higher than the expense ratio of a broad index fund, which can be a few hundredths of a percent a year.
- Diminishing harvests. Losses are easiest to find in the first years. As markets rise over time, most positions come to stand at a gain and little is left to harvest unless new cash is added.
- Dependence on tax position. The benefit requires taxable gains to offset. It is of no use inside a tax-sheltered retirement account and of little use to an investor in a low tax bracket.
- Tracking difference. Exclusions, sampling and harvesting all pull returns away from the benchmark, in either direction.
- Complexity. Hundreds of positions produce long tax reports and make it harder to move the account or to unwind it without realizing gains. Losses harvested in one account can be undone by purchases in another.
Comparison with funds
Exchange-traded funds are already tax-efficient, because their structure lets them shed low-cost shares without distributing gains to holders, so the comparison turns on whether harvesting and customization are worth the extra fee and complexity. Independent studies have generally found the tax benefit to be real but variable. It is largest for investors with high tax rates, regular new contributions and gains from other sources, and it shrinks as the account ages. Providers include specialist managers, brokers and a robo-advisor or two, and the service is often delivered through an advisor-managed account. None of this alters the market risk of the underlying shares, which is the same as that of the index.