A tax loss carryforward is a provision that allows a taxpayer to apply a loss that could not be used in the year it arose against taxable income or gains in later years. The two main kinds are a net operating loss, which arises when a business's deductions exceed its income, and a net capital loss, which arises when losses on investments exceed gains. The carryforward reduces future tax bills and so has value to the taxpayer.
Carryforwards exist because income tax is assessed year by year, while business and investment results fluctuate. Without them, a company that lost money one year and made the same amount the next would pay tax as if it had been profitable throughout. Most countries allow carryforwards, often with limits on how long they last or how much can be used each year. A carryback, which applies a loss against earlier years and produces a refund, is the related but less common mechanism. The rules described here are those of the United States, administered by the Internal Revenue Service (IRS).
Net operating losses
Under the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017, net operating losses arising in tax years beginning after 2017 can be carried forward indefinitely but generally not carried back, and the deduction in any later year is limited to 80 percent of taxable income. Losses from earlier years keep the older rules, which allowed a two-year carryback and a 20-year carryforward without the 80 percent cap. The CARES Act of 2020 temporarily allowed losses from 2018 to 2020 to be carried back five years and suspended the 80 percent limit, as a pandemic relief measure. Special rules apply to farming losses and to insurance companies.
Worked example
For a company with a carryforward, the deduction available in a year is:
Here is the deduction allowed, the carryforward balance at the start of the year and the year's taxable income before the deduction. Suppose a company enters the year with a carryforward of $1,000,000 and earns taxable income of $800,000. The cap is , so it deducts $640,000 and pays tax on $160,000. At the 21 percent federal corporate rate, tax falls by dollars. The remaining is carried into the next year.
Capital losses
Individuals first set capital losses against capital gains. If losses exceed gains, up to $3,000 of the net loss a year, or $1,500 for a married person filing separately, may be deducted from ordinary income, and the rest is carried forward without time limit. Carried-forward losses keep their character as short-term or long-term and are used first against gains of the same type. Losses realised through tax-loss harvesting therefore often take years to use in full, and they are lost on death. A loss disallowed under the wash sale rule is not carried forward but added to the cost basis of the replacement shares. Corporations may use capital losses only against capital gains, with a three-year carryback and a five-year carryforward.
Accounting treatment
In financial statements, an unused carryforward is recorded as a deferred tax asset equal to the expected future tax saving. Under US accounting standards, a company must set up a valuation allowance against the asset if it is more likely than not that the losses will not be used, for example after several years of losses. Releasing the allowance when profitability returns can produce a large one-off gain in reported earnings, which analysts usually strip out. Carryforwards are disclosed in the notes on income tax expense.
Limits on transfer
Because carryforwards are valuable, tax law restricts buying companies mainly to use their losses. Section 382 of the Internal Revenue Code limits the annual use of losses after an ownership change, broadly a shift of more than 50 percentage points in ownership by major shareholders over three years. The annual limit equals the value of the loss company times a published long-term tax-exempt rate, which can make large carryforwards almost worthless after an acquisition. Companies with large losses sometimes adopt tax benefit preservation plans, similar to a shareholder rights plan, to deter investors from building stakes that could trigger the limit.
Uses and limitations
For investors, a company's carryforwards can mean a period of low cash taxes once it returns to profit, which affects valuation and free cash flow forecasts. Their worth depends on the company actually earning enough taxable income, on future tax rates, and on the timing of use, so analysts discount them. Rules change often: limits, carryback periods and rates have been altered several times since 2017, and state rules frequently differ from federal ones. Taxpayers should rely on current law and professional advice rather than general descriptions.