A swap dealer is a firm that deals in swaps as a business, as defined in the Commodity Exchange Act by Title VII of the US Dodd-Frank Act of 2010, and that must register with the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) and meet capital, margin, conduct and reporting requirements. Most swap dealers are large banks and their affiliates that stand ready to enter into interest rate swaps, currency swaps, commodity swaps and other derivatives with corporate, institutional and other dealer counterparties.
The category was created because before 2010 the US over-the-counter derivatives market had no comprehensive regulation of the firms at its centre. Its counterpart for security-based swaps, such as single-name credit default swaps and swaps on single securities, is the security-based swap dealer, regulated by the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). A separate category, the major swap participant, covers non-dealers with very large swap positions. The definitions were set out in joint CFTC and SEC rules, summarised in Dodd-Frank Swap Entity and Product Definitions.
Legal definition
The statute describes a swap dealer as any person that does one or more of the following:
- Holds itself out as a dealer in swaps.
- Makes a market in swaps, acting as a market maker by quoting prices to both sides.
- Regularly enters into swaps with counterparties as an ordinary course of business for its own account.
- Engages in activity that causes it to be commonly known in the trade as a dealer or market maker in swaps.
The definition excludes a person that enters into swaps for its own account but not as part of a regular business, which keeps most corporate hedgers and investment funds outside it. It also excludes swaps that an insured bank enters into with a customer in connection with originating a loan to that customer, so a bank that provides an interest rate hedge alongside a loan is not treated as dealing for that reason alone. Regulators apply a facts-and-circumstances test, looking at whether a firm accommodates demand from others, seeks out counterparties and earns a spread, rather than taking positions to express its own view.
De minimis exception
A firm that deals in swaps only on a small scale is not required to register. Under the CFTC rule, the test is the aggregate gross notional amount of swaps entered into in a dealing capacity over the preceding twelve months. The threshold was set at 8 billion dollars during a phase-in period, with a scheduled fall to 3 billion dollars, but in 2018 the CFTC fixed it at 8 billion dollars. A much lower threshold of 25 million dollars applies to dealing swaps with "special entities", such as US state and local governments and public pension plans. The SEC applies its own de minimis thresholds to security-based swap dealing.
Registration and supervision
Swap dealer registration began at the end of 2012. Firms apply through the National Futures Association (NFA), which processes registrations on the CFTC's behalf, becomes the dealer's self-regulatory organisation and examines its compliance. Each swap dealer must designate a chief compliance officer who reports annually on the firm's compliance. Security-based swap dealers register directly with the SEC, under a regime whose compliance date fell in late 2021.
Where the swap dealer is itself a bank, the US prudential regulators, such as the Federal Reserve and the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency, set its capital and margin rules, while the CFTC remains responsible for its business conduct. Non-bank swap dealers follow CFTC capital rules finalised in 2020. Foreign dealers may in some cases rely on substituted compliance with home-country rules that the CFTC has found comparable.
Main obligations
Registered swap dealers carry a set of duties designed to reduce counterparty credit risk and to protect their clients:
- Capital. Holding regulatory capital against the risks of the dealing business, in line with the broader idea of a capital requirement.
- Margin for uncleared swaps. Collecting and posting variation margin and, for larger counterparties, initial margin, under rules phased in from 2016.
- Business conduct. Verifying that counterparties are eligible, disclosing material risks, characteristics and conflicts of interest before a trade, providing the daily mid-market mark, and following extra rules when dealing with special entities.
- Reporting and recordkeeping. Reporting trades to swap data repositories, keeping detailed trade records, including records of trade communications, and carrying out portfolio reconciliation and compression with other dealers.
- Clearing and execution. Clearing swaps covered by the mandate and trading them on a swap execution facility where required, as described in Dodd-Frank Swap Clearing, Trading and Reporting Rules.
Swap dealers that are part of banking groups are also affected by the Volcker Rule, which limits proprietary trading by banking entities but allows market making to meet client demand.
Criticism and debate
Industry groups such as the International Swaps and Derivatives Association (ISDA) argued that the original thresholds and cross-border rules were costly and fragmented liquidity between US and non-US dealers. Supporters of the regime argued that the de minimis threshold left too much dealing unregistered and that substituted compliance weakened oversight of foreign affiliates. The debate has centred on where the threshold should sit and how far US rules should reach overseas branches.
External links
Ref 1100001912