The National Futures Association (NFA) is the self-regulatory organization for the derivatives industry in the United States. It registers firms and individuals, writes conduct rules, audits members and disciplines those who break the rules, for businesses that deal with customers in futures, options on futures, retail foreign exchange and swaps. Membership is compulsory: a firm registered with the Commodity Futures Trading Commission in one of the main intermediary categories generally cannot do business with the public unless it belongs to the NFA.
The NFA is a private, non-profit body funded by membership dues and by fees charged on futures transactions. It operates under the oversight of the CFTC, which must approve its rules and which can review its disciplinary decisions. It is often compared with the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority, its counterpart in the securities industry. The NFA is based in Chicago and also has an office in New York.
History
Amendments to the Commodity Exchange Act in 1974, which also created the CFTC, allowed the industry to form registered futures associations that would regulate their members under federal supervision. The NFA was designated as such an association by the CFTC in 1981 and began operating in 1982. Before then, oversight of brokers dealing with the public was split between the exchanges, which regulated their own members, and the CFTC itself. A single industry-wide body brought firms that were not exchange members under one set of conduct rules.
Its remit has grown with the law. Rules on retail foreign exchange brought forex dealers into membership, and after the Dodd-Frank Act of 2010 the NFA took on the registration and supervision of swap dealers and major swap participants.
Membership and registration
The main categories of member are:
- Futures commission merchants. A futures commission merchant accepts customer orders and holds customer money and collateral.
- Introducing brokers. An introducing broker solicits and accepts orders but passes them, and the customer funds, to a futures commission merchant.
- Pool operators and trading advisors. A commodity pool operator runs collective funds that trade futures, and a commodity trading advisor gives trading advice for pay.
- Retail foreign exchange dealers, swap dealers and major swap participants. These firms deal directly with customers or other counterparties in forex or swaps.
The CFTC has delegated much of the registration process to the NFA, which screens applicants, checks backgrounds and fingerprints, and confirms that individuals have passed the required proficiency examinations. Individuals who solicit orders or supervise others on behalf of a member register as an associated person. Registration and disciplinary histories are published in an online database called BASIC, the Background Affiliation Status Information Center, which the public can search before choosing a firm.
Rules and supervision
The NFA's rulebook covers sales practices, promotional material, the handling of customer orders and funds, the disclosure of risks, capital requirements for certain members, and anti-fraud standards. Members must keep records, file financial reports and submit to periodic examinations. For many futures commission merchants that are not members of an exchange, the NFA acts as the designated self-regulatory organization responsible for monitoring their capital and the segregation of customer funds.
It also conducts surveillance of market activity for some exchanges under service agreements, and it administers customer disputes through an arbitration programme that offers an alternative to the courts for claims against members.
Enforcement
When an examination or complaint uncovers a possible violation, the NFA's staff investigate and may refer the matter to a committee that can issue a formal complaint. Cases are decided by hearing panels, and penalties include fines, suspension, expulsion and bans on future membership. In urgent cases, such as a firm that may be misusing customer money, the NFA can take emergency action to restrict a member's business immediately. Because no non-member can deal with the public in most categories, expulsion effectively ends a firm's ability to operate in the US futures business.
Criticism
Like other self-regulatory organizations, the NFA has been criticised for potential conflicts of interest, since it is funded and governed in part by the firms it supervises. Failures of futures brokers in the early 2010s, in which customer money was found to be missing, led to questions about how well self-regulators had monitored segregated funds, and to tighter rules on reporting customer balances. Supporters argue that an industry body with specialist staff can act faster and more cheaply than a government agency alone.