A swap execution facility (SEF) is a trading venue in the United States on which multiple participants can execute or trade swaps by accepting bids and offers from multiple other participants. SEFs were created by Title VII of the Dodd-Frank Act of 2010 and are registered with and regulated by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC). They host trading in products such as interest rate swaps, index credit default swaps, foreign exchange non-deliverable forwards and some commodity swaps.
The aim was to move standardised over-the-counter derivatives, which before the 2008 financial crisis were traded largely by telephone between dealers and clients, onto transparent and regulated platforms. SEFs work alongside mandatory central clearing and trade reporting, the other pillars of the post-crisis reform of swap markets. Many SEFs are operated by interdealer brokers, electronic trading firms and exchange groups.
Legal basis and registration
Dodd-Frank amended the Commodity Exchange Act to define a SEF and to require any facility for trading or processing swaps to register either as a SEF or as a designated contract market (DCM), the category that covers futures exchanges. The CFTC adopted its main SEF rules in 2013, and the first platforms registered later that year. A SEF must comply with a set of core principles covering matters such as impartial access, monitoring of trading and trade processing, prevention of market abuse, recordkeeping, financial resources, conflicts of interest and system safeguards. It must also have a chief compliance officer and rules that bind its participants.
Impartial access means that a SEF must admit any eligible participant on fair, open and non-discriminatory terms, rather than restricting trading to a closed club of dealers. Each trade executed on the platform must be reported to a registered swap data repository, and the SEF must publish price and volume information in real time, subject to delays for large trades. These transparency rules were intended to give buy-side firms such as asset managers and pension funds a clearer view of prevailing prices.
Security-based swaps, such as single-name credit default swaps, fall under the Securities and Exchange Commission rather than the CFTC, and the SEC has developed a parallel regime for security-based swap execution facilities.
The trade execution requirement
The core of the SEF regime is the trade execution requirement. A swap that is subject to the clearing mandate must be executed on a SEF or DCM once it has been made available to trade, a determination that a platform can submit to the CFTC for particular contracts. The first such determinations took effect in early 2014 for benchmark interest rate swaps in major currencies and for the most liquid credit default swap indices. Swaps covered by the requirement are called required transactions; all others are permitted transactions.
Exemptions apply to some trades, including transactions between affiliates and certain trades by end-users that qualify for an exception from clearing. Large block trades above set size thresholds may be negotiated away from the platform's normal methods and receive delayed public reporting, to protect parties from adverse price moves.
Execution methods
For required transactions, the CFTC's rules allow two main execution methods:
- An order book, in which participants post firm bids and offers that all other participants can see and trade against, similar to a central limit order book on an exchange.
- A request for quote (RFQ) system, in which a participant asks for prices from a minimum number of other participants, set at three under the CFTC's rules, and must be able to see any resting bids and offers in the order book at the same time.
For permitted transactions a SEF may offer any method of execution, including voice broking. In practice dealer-to-client trading is dominated by RFQ platforms, while dealer-to-dealer trading takes place on order books and hybrid systems run by interdealer brokers. Critics have argued that the rules are complex and fragment liquidity, and the CFTC has consulted on reforms more than once.
Comparison with EU venues
The European Union took a similar path under MiFIR, which imposes a derivatives trading obligation for certain clearable, liquid derivatives. In the EU these must be traded on a regulated market, a multilateral trading facility (MTF) or an organised trading facility (OTF), a venue type introduced partly to capture broker platforms similar to SEFs. Because many swaps are traded across the Atlantic, the CFTC and the European Commission have taken steps to recognise each other's venues so that firms can meet both trading requirements on a single platform.
External links
Ref 1100001602