Commercial appraisal standards and assumptions are the rules and choices that determine how an appraiser reaches a value for a commercial property or other collateral that a lender relies on. In the United States the starting point is a professional standard that governs how appraisals are developed and reported. Within that standard, appraisers make assumptions, estimate how long a sale would take, and decide whether a full inspection is needed.
Lenders, examiners and credit committees read an appraisal report with these elements in mind, because they determine how far the stated value can be trusted when a loan is sized against it or the collateral must later be sold. The members of this family move from the overarching standard, to assumptions inside a single assignment, to the time frame behind a value, to a lighter form of appraisal done without a site visit.
Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice (USPAP)
The Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice (USPAP) are the generally recognised quality standards for appraisal practice in the United States. They are written and periodically updated by the Appraisal Standards Board of The Appraisal Foundation, a non-profit organisation that Congress gave a formal role after the savings and loan crisis, under Title XI of the Financial Institutions Reform, Recovery, and Enforcement Act of 1989.
USPAP sets ethics, competency and record-keeping rules and separate standards for real property, personal property and business valuation. Appraisals for federally related transactions by regulated lenders must be prepared by a state-licensed or certified appraiser (real estate) in line with USPAP and the banking agencies' appraisal rules. Below regulatory thresholds, lenders may instead use an evaluation, which need not follow USPAP. Because the text is revised from time to time, appraisers state which edition applies to each assignment.
Extraordinary Assumption
An extraordinary assumption, in USPAP terms, is an assumption made for a specific assignment about something uncertain at the effective date of the valuation which, if found to be false, could change the appraiser's opinions or conclusions. Examples include assuming that a pending environmental report will show no contamination, that a roof is sound when it could not be inspected, or that leases provided by the owner are accurate.
It differs from a hypothetical condition, which is something known to be contrary to fact but assumed for the purpose of analysis, such as valuing a building as if already completed. USPAP allows an extraordinary assumption only if it is required for credible results, has a reasonable basis and is clearly disclosed, together with a statement that its use might have affected the results. Credit officers look for these disclosures because they show where the appraised value depends on facts not yet confirmed.
Marketing Period
The marketing period is the appraiser's estimate of how long it would take to sell a property at the appraised value, measured forward from the effective date of the valuation. It is a prospective figure and is often given as a range, for example six to twelve months for a suburban office building in a soft market.
It is distinct from exposure time, a related concept that estimates how long the property would have had to be on the market before the effective date for a sale at the appraised market value to have taken place. Exposure time is retrospective and is built into the market value definition; the marketing period looks ahead. Lenders care about the marketing period because a long one means more carrying costs, interest and price risk if they must take back and sell the collateral, which affects real estate loan workout plans and liquidation estimates.
Desktop Appraisal
A desktop appraisal is a valuation done without the appraiser visiting the property. The appraiser relies on public records, listing and sales data, photographs, floor plans and information from the owner or lender, and may combine these with output from an automated valuation model (AVM).
Lenders accept desktop work where the risk of a missed physical problem is low or where a recent full appraisal exists. In asset-based lending, interim updates of inventory or machinery values are often done on a desktop basis between full field appraisals. Some residential mortgage programmes have also allowed desktop appraisals for certain loans. The main risks are that condition problems, unpermitted changes or neighbourhood issues go unseen, so desktop reports normally carry extraordinary assumptions about the property's condition. Regulators expect lenders to have policies setting out when such a product is acceptable.
External links
Ref 1180001851