Rational pricing is the principle that prices should leave no room for riskless profit: two assets or portfolios that produce exactly the same cash flows in every circumstance must trade at the same price. Otherwise a trader could buy the cheaper, sell the dearer and lock in a riskless gain, and that trading would push the prices together. It underpins the valuation of forwards, futures, options, swaps and bonds.
Rational pricing is closely linked to the law of one price and to the idea of a replicating portfolio, a combination of simple instruments that copies a derivative's payoff. It does not say what an asset is fundamentally worth; it says only how the prices of related instruments must line up with one another. It assumes free borrowing, lending and short selling at low cost, so it holds most tightly in deep, liquid markets.
The law of one price and arbitrage
The starting point is the law of one price: the same good, or the same set of cash flows, should have one price across markets once transport and transaction costs are allowed for. Arbitrage is the mechanism that enforces it. In financial markets the good is usually a stream of payments, so the comparison is between an instrument and a package of other instruments that pays the same amounts at the same times.
Arbitrage in the strict sense needs no net investment and carries no risk, yet pays something positive in at least one outcome. Rational pricing holds that such opportunities are absent, or disappear quickly when they appear. The same reasoning ties currency forward rates to interest rate differences, stock index futures to the shares in the index, and exchange-traded fund prices to the value of the underlying basket.
Forward prices from spot plus carry
A forward contract can be copied by buying the underlying asset today with borrowed money and holding it until the delivery date. The forward price must therefore equal the spot price plus the cost of carry, less any income the asset pays. For an asset with no income and no storage cost, the relationship is:
- is the forward price agreed today.
- is the spot price of the asset today.
- is the annual risk-free interest rate, as a decimal.
- is the time to delivery in years.
With a spot price of 1,000, a rate of 4% and six months to delivery, . If the forward traded at 1,030, a trader could borrow 1,000, buy the asset, sell it forward at 1,030 and repay 1,019.80 at delivery, keeping 10.20 without risk. Done in practice, this is a cash-and-carry trade. For commodities, storage costs raise the fair forward price and the convenience of holding physical stock lowers it, which is why commodity curves can slope either way.
Put-call parity
Options are tied to one another by the same logic. A European call option and a European put option on the same asset, with the same strike and expiry, combine to give the same payoff as holding the asset and borrowing the present value of the strike. Put-call parity states:
Here and are the call and put premiums, is the strike price, and the other symbols are as above. With , , and , the right-hand side is . If the call costs 4.00, the put should cost about 1.62. A put priced well away from that figure would allow an arbitrage by trading it against a combination of the call, the asset and borrowing. Parity needs no model of how the asset's price moves.
Bonds and discounting
A fixed-rate bond is a bundle of payments on known dates, each of which can be valued as a zero-coupon bond. Its rational price, the basis of bond pricing, is the sum of those payments discounted at the zero-coupon rate for each date:
Here is the payment in year and is the zero-coupon rate for that maturity. A two-year bond with a face value of 100 and an annual 5% coupon, with zero rates of 3% for one year and 4% for two years, is worth . If the bond traded at 103, a dealer could sell it and buy the matching zero-coupon strips more cheaply. Stripping and reconstituting bonds in this way keeps government bond prices consistent with the zero-coupon curve.
Risk-neutral valuation and limits
When a payoff can be replicated with the underlying asset and a bond paying the risk-free rate, its price does not depend on investors' attitudes to risk. That allows a shortcut: value the derivative as if all investors were indifferent to risk, take its expected payoff under the adjusted probabilities and discount at the risk-free rate. The binomial option pricing model and the Black-Scholes-Merton model both rest on this argument. The adjusted probabilities are a calculation device, not forecasts. In a complete market, where every payoff can be replicated, the no-arbitrage price is unique; otherwise rational pricing only sets a range.
Real markets meet the assumptions only partly. Trading costs, taxes and limits on short selling create a band within which prices can drift without a profitable arbitrage. During the financial crisis of 2007 to 2009, gaps opened between instruments that should have been priced alike because dealers lacked the balance sheet to close them. Rational pricing also says nothing about whether the underlying asset is fairly valued, which is a separate question from the efficient market hypothesis.
Ref 1100001907