Cost of carry is the net cost of holding an asset from now until a later date. It adds up what the holder pays, mainly interest on the money tied up plus storage and insurance for physical goods, and subtracts what the asset earns, such as dividends or coupons. In commodity markets the same costs are called a carrying charge.
The concept is the basis of pricing for a futures contract or a forward contract. Buying an asset today and holding it, or agreeing today to buy it later, are two ways to end up owning the same thing on the same date. The price for later delivery should therefore equal the spot price plus the cost of carrying the asset until then.
The cost-of-carry formula
In simple-interest form the relationship is:
- is the fair futures or forward price.
- is the spot price today.
- is the annual financing rate, often taken as the risk-free rate or a secured borrowing rate.
- is the annual cost of storage and insurance, as a fraction of the spot price.
- is the annual income or other benefit from holding the asset, as a fraction of the spot price.
- is the time to delivery in years.
The term is the cost of carry as an annual rate. Textbooks often use continuous compounding, writing , which gives almost the same answer over short periods.
Worked examples
Suppose gold is 2,000 dollars an ounce, financing costs 5 percent a year, and storage and insurance cost 0.5 percent a year. Gold pays no income. For delivery in six months, dollars. The cost of carry is 55 dollars an ounce.
For a share index the income term matters. With the index at 5,000, a financing rate of 5 percent and a dividend yield of 1.5 percent, the fair price of index futures three months ahead is . If dividends exceeded the financing rate, the carry would be negative and the futures would stand below the index.
Carry in different markets
- Commodities. Storage, insurance and financing all apply. Holders of scarce physical stock also gain a benefit known as the convenience yield, the value of having goods on hand to keep a plant running or meet a sale. It enters the formula as part of .
- Shares and indices. Carry is the financing rate less expected dividends.
- Bonds. Carry is the coupon income less the cost of financing the position, usually through a repurchase agreement. It is positive when the bond yields more than the funding rate.
- Currencies. Carry is the difference between the interest rates of the two currencies, which is what sets the price of an FX forward contract. The carry trade seeks to earn that difference without the forward hedge.
Carry and the shape of the futures curve
When carry is positive, later delivery dates are priced above nearer ones, a pattern called contango. A market in which each later month exceeds the one before by the whole cost of storage and financing is said to be at full carry, and that is normally the widest the gap can become. When the convenience yield or income is large enough to make net carry negative, later dates are cheaper, which is backwardation. This is common in commodities when stocks are low.
The gap between the futures and spot prices is the basis. Because the carry left to pay shrinks as delivery approaches, the two prices move together over the life of the contract, a process described under convergence.
Arbitrage and its limits
The formula holds because of arbitrage. If the futures price is above spot plus carry, a trader can borrow, buy the asset, sell the futures and deliver at expiry for a locked-in profit. This is called cash-and-carry. If the futures price is too low, a holder of the asset can sell it, invest the cash and buy the futures.
In practice the relationship is a band, not a single price. Transaction costs, different borrowing and lending rates, and limits on storage space all create a range in which no trade pays. The reverse trade needs someone willing to lend or sell the physical asset, which is hard for many commodities, so the formula sets a firmer ceiling than floor. Goods that cannot be stored, such as electricity, do not follow it at all. Future dividends and the convenience yield are estimates, so the fair value itself is uncertain.