P&I club agreements are arrangements among the mutual protection and indemnity clubs that insure shipowners' liabilities to third parties. They go beyond the cover each club gives to its own members and set out how claims are shared, how particular cargo claims are divided between owners and charterers, and how owners of tankers contribute to compensation funds for oil pollution. The clubs that take part in most of the arrangements are members of the International Group of P&I Clubs.
The agreements matter because a single major casualty, such as a pollution incident or a ship loss, can be far larger than one club could bear on its own. They work alongside the cover described in P&I Insurance (Protection and Indemnity) and the reinsurance purchased by the group, and they interact with the carrier liability rules of the Hague-Visby Rules and the oil pollution conventions. Figures and thresholds in these arrangements are reviewed regularly, and the sections below describe their structure rather than a current schedule.
Pooling Agreement
The pooling agreement is the arrangement under which the International Group clubs share the cost of large claims. Each club bears claims up to its retention on its own account. Claims above the retention, up to a stated pool limit, are shared among all the clubs in proportion to their experience, and claims above that level are met by the group's collective excess of loss reinsurance contract, bought on the market.
The retention has been around US$10 million per claim and the pool layer has extended to about US$100 million, with reinsurance above that, in recent years, but the amounts are reset at the annual renewal of the cover, which takes effect on 20 February. The pool means that a shipowner's cover does not depend on the strength of one club. It also gives the clubs a shared financial interest in the quality of ships entered. The structure is a form of Excess of Loss Reinsurance built on a retention layer. Owners benefit through the high limits of cover that the group can offer.
Interclub Agreement
The Interclub Agreement, in full the Interclub New York Produce Exchange Agreement, is a scheme among P&I clubs for dividing cargo claims between shipowners and charterers under certain time charters. It applies where the charterparty is on the New York Produce Exchange form or a similar form and has incorporated the agreement. Its purpose is to avoid long disputes between the owner's club and the charterer's insurer over who pays for damaged or lost cargo.
The allocation follows the cause of the claim. In outline, claims arising from unseaworthiness of the ship or from errors in navigation or management of the ship fall on the owners. Claims arising from the loading, stowage, securing, discharge or care of cargo fall on the charterers. Claims of unknown cause, or from other causes, are shared equally. The agreement also sets time limits for notifying and pursuing a recovery, and it was revised in 1996 and again in 2011. The Charterparty Standard Forms page describes the underlying forms, and Liability and Exception Clauses in Shipping Contracts covers related clauses.
Small Tanker Oil Pollution Indemnification Agreement (STOPIA)
The Small Tanker Oil Pollution Indemnification Agreement, STOPIA, is a voluntary agreement among owners of smaller tankers, put into effect through the International Group clubs. Under the international oil pollution compensation regime, the shipowner's liability is limited by tonnage, and the International Oil Pollution Compensation (IOPC) Funds pay compensation above that limit. For small tankers the limit is low.
Under STOPIA, the owner of an entered tanker agrees to reimburse the IOPC Fund for the part of the claims paid by the Fund that falls between the owner's statutory limit and a higher figure of 20 million special drawing rights, so that the owner of a small tanker bears a larger share of its own pollution costs. It was adopted in 2006, with effect from 20 February that year, and covers tankers up to a gross tonnage of about 29,548. The agreement is not a convention. It is a contractual undertaking by owners, and it is amended by the clubs from time to time. It is linked to IMO Conventions, Codes and Ship Certificates.
Tanker Oil Pollution Indemnification Agreement (TOPIA)
The Tanker Oil Pollution Indemnification Agreement, TOPIA, is the companion to STOPIA for larger tankers and for pollution incidents that reach the highest layer of compensation. It applies where a state has joined the Supplementary Fund Protocol of 2003, which gives an extra layer of compensation above the funds available under the 1992 regime.
Under TOPIA, shipowners reimburse the Supplementary Fund for a share of what it pays, generally 50 percent, so that owners contribute to the highest layer and not only to the lower ones. Like STOPIA, it was introduced in 2006 and is operated through the International Group of P&I Clubs, and it is a voluntary agreement and not part of the treaties themselves. Taken together, STOPIA and TOPIA are intended to keep the cost of oil pollution from falling too heavily on the compensation funds, which are financed by oil importers. The cover for these liabilities is a form of Marine Insurance provided by mutual clubs.
Ref 1170000343