Payment protection insurance (PPI) is a type of creditor insurance sold with credit products in the United Kingdom, such as personal loans, credit cards, store cards, car finance and mortgages. It is designed to meet the borrower's repayments for a limited period if they cannot work because of accident or sickness, or if they become unemployed, and some policies also pay off the debt on death. Similar products exist in other countries under names such as credit protection or loan protection insurance.
PPI is best known for the mis-selling scandal that followed its mass distribution by banks and other lenders from the 1990s to the late 2000s. Millions of policies were sold to customers who did not need them, could not claim on them or did not know they had bought them. The resulting compensation programme became the largest consumer redress exercise in UK financial history, and the scandal reshaped how regulators approach conduct in retail finance.
How the product worked
A PPI policy paid a monthly benefit equal to the borrower's loan or card repayment, usually after a waiting period and for up to one or two years per claim. Premiums were charged in different ways:
- Single premium. The whole cost was added to the loan at the start, so the borrower paid interest on it and often lost value if the loan was repaid early.
- Regular premium. A monthly charge was taken with the repayment, or for credit cards as a percentage of the outstanding balance.
- Bundled cover. The policy came packaged with the loan, a practice discussed under bundling.
Lenders typically acted as intermediaries for an insurer, often one in their own group, and received high commissions on each sale. Claims ratios, the share of premiums paid out in claims, were low compared with other insurance products, which made PPI very profitable. Policies also carried exclusions for pre-existing medical conditions and for the self-employed or those on short contracts, which meant many policyholders could never have claimed. Unlike stand-alone income protection, the cover was tied to a single debt.
The mis-selling scandal
Concerns grew during the 2000s. Consumer groups complained about pressure selling at the point of sale, and the Financial Services Authority (FSA), which began regulating general insurance sales in 2005, found widespread failings in how firms sold the product. A market investigation by the competition authorities concluded that the lack of competition at the point of sale harmed customers, and its remedies included a ban on selling PPI at the same time as the credit it covered.
In 2010 the FSA set out rules on how firms should handle PPI complaints. The British Bankers' Association challenged them through judicial review, but lost in the High Court in 2011, after which the major banks set aside large provisions to compensate customers. Complaints flooded the Financial Ombudsman Service, which for several years handled more PPI cases than all other financial products combined. A claims management industry grew up around the scandal, contacting consumers by phone and text message to pursue claims in exchange for a share of the payout.
In 2014 the Supreme Court ruled in Plevin v Paragon Personal Finance that failing to disclose a very large commission on a PPI sale could make the relationship between lender and borrower unfair under the Consumer Credit Act 1974. This widened the grounds for claims, because customers who could not show mis-selling might still be owed part of their premiums back if commission had been high and undisclosed.
Redress and the claims deadline
Firms refunded the premiums paid, plus interest at a statutory rate, and in some cases the extra interest on the loan caused by a single premium. The Financial Conduct Authority (FCA), which replaced the FSA in 2013, set a final deadline of 29 August 2019 for new complaints, backed by a national advertising campaign. Applications rose sharply before the cut-off. Total compensation paid between 2011 and the wind-down of the programme was reported at more than £38 billion, making PPI by far the costliest conduct failure for UK lenders.
Legacy
The PPI episode influenced later conduct regulation. It strengthened the focus on product design and on whether products deliver fair value, on complaint handling, and on firms' conduct risk frameworks, themes later found in the FCA's Consumer Duty. It also led to closer regulation of claims management companies, which came under the FCA in 2019. Payment protection products are still sold, but with greater emphasis on eligibility checks and on separating the insurance decision from the decision to take consumer credit.
External links
Ref 1170000295