The new issue rule is the common name for Rule 5130 of the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA), which restricts the purchase and sale of shares in an equity initial public offering in the United States. A FINRA member firm may not sell a new issue to an account in which a restricted person has a beneficial interest, and may not keep new issue shares for its own account. The aim is to make sure that IPO shares are offered to the public in good faith rather than diverted to people in the securities industry.
The rule matters most for popular offerings, which often open well above the offering price. Without restrictions, firms and their staff could take the cheap allocations for themselves or their friends and sell at a quick profit. FINRA's predecessor dealt with this through a free-riding and withholding interpretation dating back decades. Rule 5130, first adopted in 2003 as NASD Rule 2790, replaced it with clearer definitions and became part of the consolidated FINRA rulebook. It applies to every broker-dealer that is a FINRA member and that takes part in, or sells shares from, an IPO.
What counts as a new issue
A new issue is any initial public offering of an equity security made under a registration statement or offering circular. The rule lists many exclusions, including:
- Non-IPO offerings. Secondary offerings of a company that is already public, rights offerings and exchange offers.
- Non-equity and hybrid securities. Debt, preferred stock, convertible securities and investment-grade asset-backed securities.
- Private and offshore sales. Offerings exempt from registration, such as sales to qualified institutional buyers under Rule 144A and offshore sales under Regulation S.
- Certain funds. Offerings by registered investment companies and some other pooled vehicles.
Restricted persons
The rule defines who may not benefit from new issue allocations. Restricted persons include:
- FINRA member firms and other broker-dealers, and their officers, directors, general partners and employees.
- Finders and fiduciaries acting for the managing underwriter, such as lawyers and accountants involved in the offering.
- Portfolio managers who buy and sell securities for banks, insurers, an investment adviser or similar institutional accounts.
- Persons with significant ownership of a broker-dealer.
- Immediate family members of most of the above, where the restricted person supports them financially or can influence the allocation.
An account is affected only if a restricted person holds a beneficial ownership interest in it. A de minimis exemption allows sales to an account, such as a hedge fund, in which restricted persons together hold no more than 10 percent. Funds can also carve out restricted investors so that they do not share in new issue profits.
General exemptions
Some buyers are outside the rule altogether, whoever their beneficiaries are. They include registered investment companies such as mutual funds, the general or separate accounts of insurance companies, common trust funds, publicly traded companies other than broker-dealers, many employee benefit plans, state and municipal government plans, tax-exempt charities and church plans. Shares sold under an issuer-directed programme, for example to employees and directors of the issuer, are also exempt in many cases.
Compliance and enforcement
Before selling a new issue to an account, a firm must obtain, within the previous 12 months, a representation from the account holder or an authorized person that the account is eligible. It must then reconfirm eligibility at least once a year, usually through a negative-consent letter or a signed questionnaire. Firms build these checks into their IPO allocation process and keep records of each verification.
FINRA examines member firms for compliance and brings disciplinary cases for violations, which can lead to fines, disgorgement of profits and suspensions. A companion rule, Rule 5131, in force since 2011 after the scandals of the dot-com era, targets other allocation abuses. It prohibits quid pro quo allocations in exchange for excessive commissions, bans spinning, meaning the allocation of IPO shares to executives of companies that are or may become investment banking clients, and sets rules on flipping penalties and lock-up releases.
Criticism
The rule is complex, and its definitions of family members, beneficial interests and exempt accounts generate a large compliance burden for funds and brokers, especially smaller ones. Critics also point out that it addresses only one route by which favoured investors gain from underpriced IPOs. The broader pricing process, including book building and discretionary allocation to institutions, remains a subject of academic and policy debate.