Securities lending, also called stock borrow and loan, is the temporary transfer of securities from one party to another in return for collateral and a fee. The borrower receives legal title to the shares or bonds and must return equivalent securities when the loan ends, either on a set date or when either side calls for it. The lender keeps the economic exposure to the securities: it receives payments equal to any dividends or interest paid during the loan, and it gains or loses as the price moves.
The market exists mainly to supply securities for short selling, for settling trades that would otherwise fail and for hedging and market making. It is closely related to the repurchase agreement market, which serves a similar function for bonds but is driven mainly by the need for cash financing rather than the need for particular securities. Large asset owners earn extra income from lending holdings that would otherwise sit idle.
Participants
- Lenders. Pension funds, insurers, mutual funds, exchange-traded funds, sovereign wealth funds and endowments, which hold large, long-term portfolios. Many retail brokers also run programmes for lending customers' fully paid shares.
- Agent lenders. Most institutions lend through an agent, usually a custodian bank or a specialist firm, which finds borrowers, manages collateral and shares the revenue.
- Borrowers. Broker-dealers and prime brokers, which borrow on behalf of hedge funds and other short sellers and for their own trading and settlement needs.
In the United States, rules on short sales require a broker to have borrowed the shares, arranged to borrow them, or have reasonable grounds to believe they can be borrowed before accepting a short sale order. Broker lists of easy-to-borrow stocks and checks on share availability serve this requirement.
Collateral, fees and rebates
Loans are collateralised above their value, typically at around 102 percent for domestic securities and 105 percent for foreign ones, and marked to market daily. Collateral may be other securities, in which case the borrower pays a fee, or cash, in which case the lender pays the borrower interest on the cash, known as the rebate, and earns by reinvesting the cash at a higher rate. Lending fees depend on demand: widely available stocks lend at low general collateral rates, while hard-to-borrow stocks command high fees and can carry negative rebates.
For a loan against non-cash collateral, the fee accrues as:
Here is the market value of the securities on loan, is the annual fee rate and is the number of days the loan is outstanding, on the money-market convention of a 360-day year. A loan of $1,000,000 of shares at a fee of 0.50 percent for 30 days earns , or about $416.67. If the same shares became hard to borrow and the fee rose to 20 percent, the 30-day fee would be about $16,667.
Life of a loan
A loan begins when the lender delivers the securities, which the borrower may then sell or redeliver. Either side can then change or end it:
- Rerate. The fee or rebate can be renegotiated as demand changes, a process called a rerate.
- Recall. The lender can recall the securities, for instance to sell them or to vote at a shareholder meeting; a loan recall obliges the borrower to return them or find another lender.
- Return. The borrower ends the loan by a return of equivalent securities, and the collateral is released.
A borrower unable to return recalled shares may face a buy-in, in which the shares are bought in the market at its expense.
Risks and regulation
The main risk for the lender is that a borrower defaults when the collateral is worth less than the cost of replacing the securities, which agents often cover by an indemnity. The larger risk has often been the reinvestment of cash collateral: during the 2008 financial crisis, several lenders, including the insurer AIG, suffered heavy losses after investing cash collateral in mortgage-linked securities that fell in value and became illiquid. Lenders also give up voting rights on lent shares unless they recall them, which matters for governance.
Regulators treat securities lending as part of the wider system of securities financing transactions. Rules cover collateral, capital, and reporting of loans to supervisors, and the European Union requires such transactions to be reported to trade repositories. Critics argue that lending facilitates aggressive short selling, while supporters point to its role in market liquidity, price discovery and settlement efficiency.