Monopolistic competition is a market structure in which many firms sell products that are similar but not identical, entry and exit are relatively easy, and each firm has some power to set its own price. Restaurants, clothing brands, hair salons, coffee shops and many local services are standard examples. Each seller offers something slightly different, such as a recipe, a location or a style, so it faces a downward-sloping demand curve rather than having to accept a market price.
The model was developed separately in 1933 by the American economist Edward Chamberlin, in The Theory of Monopolistic Competition, and the British economist Joan Robinson, in The Economics of Imperfect Competition. It sits between perfect competition, with many firms selling identical goods, and oligopoly, with a few large firms that watch each other closely. It combines the many small firms of the first with the price-setting power of a monopoly, and it is part of the wider study of market structure and market power.
Main features
Economists describe monopolistic competition by four features:
- Many sellers. Each firm is small relative to the market, so its decisions have little effect on any single rival, and firms do not need to plan around each other's reactions as oligopolists do.
- Differentiated products. Buyers see each firm's product as somewhat distinct, which gives the firm a loyal group of customers and some control over price.
- Low barriers to entry. New firms can open and existing ones can close without large costs, so profits attract newcomers.
- Non-price competition. Firms compete through branding, advertising, quality and service as well as through price.
Because products differ, demand for each firm is fairly elastic but not perfectly so: raising its price loses some customers to close substitutes, but not all of them.
Short-run and long-run equilibrium
Like any firm with pricing power, a monopolistically competitive firm maximises profit by producing where marginal revenue equals marginal cost:
and then charging the highest price its demand curve allows at that quantity. Suppose a café faces demand , so marginal revenue is , and it has a constant marginal cost of 10 and fixed costs of 200 a day. Setting gives and a price of . Revenue is , total cost is , and the economic profit is 200.
That profit does not last. Because entry is easy, new cafés open nearby, taking some customers and shifting each existing firm's demand curve to the left. Entry continues until economic profit is zero, which happens when the demand curve just touches the firm's average total cost curve at the profit-maximising output, a tangency solution. If firms are making losses, some leave and the remaining firms' demand recovers. In long-run equilibrium, therefore, price equals average total cost but stays above marginal cost, the gap being the firm's markup.
Excess capacity and efficiency
At the long-run tangency point the demand curve slopes down, so it touches the average cost curve to the left of its lowest point. Each firm therefore produces less than the output that would minimise its average cost, a result known as excess capacity: the industry has more firms, each operating below its most efficient scale, than the cheapest possible arrangement would need. The shape of these curves is explained under cost curves of the firm.
Monopolistic competition thus falls short of both productive efficiency, since output is not at minimum average cost, and allocative efficiency, since price exceeds marginal cost and some trades that would benefit both sides do not happen. Chamberlin and later writers argued that this is partly the cost of variety. Buyers value a choice of restaurants, styles and locations, and a world of identical, lowest-cost products would serve many of them worse. Whether the market offers too much or too little variety cannot be settled in general.
Differentiated Product
A differentiated product is one that buyers see as distinct from rival products even when the products serve the same purpose. Differences can be real, such as taste, quality, design, features or speed of service; they can come from location, since a shop on the corner is more convenient than an identical one across town; or they can be created mainly by branding and image. Differentiation is what gives a firm under monopolistic competition its downward-sloping demand curve: some customers will pay a little more for the version they prefer, so the firm can raise its price without losing all its sales. The more distinct a product appears, the less elastic its demand and the larger the markup it can sustain. Retail banking offers an example: current accounts are broadly similar, but banks differentiate them through branch networks, mobile apps, rewards and customer service, which lets them charge different fees and pay different rates on deposits.
Non-Price Competition
Non-price competition is rivalry between firms through means other than price: advertising, branding, packaging, product quality and design, location, opening hours, loyalty schemes, warranties and after-sales service. It is typical of monopolistic competition and oligopoly, where firms have reasons to avoid price wars and can win customers by making their product seem more attractive or more different. Under monopolistic competition, advertising can inform buyers about prices and new products, which helps competition, but it can also build brand loyalty that makes demand less sensitive to price. Spending on advertising and product changes raises costs, and economists debate whether such spending mainly informs consumers or mainly persuades them. Non-price competition is also prominent in payments and card markets, where issuers compete through rewards, perks and app features rather than by cutting headline fees.
Comparison with other market structures
| Feature | Perfect competition | Monopolistic competition | Oligopoly | Monopoly |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Number of firms | Very many | Many | Few | One |
| Product | Identical | Differentiated | Identical or differentiated | Unique |
| Entry | Free | Easy | Difficult | Blocked |
| Long-run economic profit | Zero | Zero | Can be positive | Can be positive |
| Price and marginal cost | Equal | Price above MC | Price above MC | Price above MC |
Concentration measures such as the Herfindahl-Hirschman Index are low in monopolistically competitive markets, which is why competition authorities rarely intervene in them.
Ref 1100001713