The Herfindahl-Hirschman Index (HHI) is a measure of how concentrated a market is, calculated by squaring the market share of every firm and adding the results. With shares written as percentages, the index runs from close to zero, for a market split among countless tiny firms, to 10,000, for a market held entirely by one firm. Competition authorities, economists and courts use it as a quick, standard gauge of how much rivalry a market has.
The index is named after the economists Orris Herfindahl and Albert Hirschman, who developed versions of it independently in the mid-twentieth century. It is most closely associated with merger control, where antitrust agencies compare the HHI before and after a proposed deal. It sits alongside the simpler concentration ratio, and both are tools for describing market structure and market power, from perfect competition to monopoly.
How the index is calculated
The HHI is the sum of the squared shares of all firms in the market:
Here is the market share of firm , in per cent, and is the number of firms. Squaring gives large firms far more weight than small ones, so the index reacts strongly to a dominant player.
Take a market with four firms holding 40, 30, 20 and 10 per cent. The index is . If the two smallest firms merge into one firm with 30 per cent, the new index is , a rise of 400. That change always equals twice the product of the merging firms' shares, here . For comparison, ten equal firms of 10 per cent each give an HHI of , and a pure monopoly gives . Some authors write shares as decimals, giving a scale from 0 to 1.
Use in merger review
In the United States, the Department of Justice and the Federal Trade Commission have used the HHI in their merger guidelines since 1982. Under the 2010 Horizontal Merger Guidelines, markets with an HHI below 1,500 were treated as unconcentrated, those between 1,500 and 2,500 as moderately concentrated, and those above 2,500 as highly concentrated. The 2023 Merger Guidelines lowered the line for a highly concentrated market to 1,800 and treat a merger as presumed to substantially lessen competition if it produces an HHI above 1,800 together with an increase of more than 100 points. In the worked example above, both tests are met.
The thresholds are screening tools, not automatic rules. Agencies also weigh barriers to entry, the closeness of competition between the merging firms, likely efficiencies and the risk of coordination, as in a cartel. Other authorities, including the European Commission and the UK Competition and Markets Authority, also report HHI levels and changes in their assessments of mergers and acquisitions.
Concentration Ratio
A concentration ratio is the combined market share of the largest few firms in an industry. The most common version is the four-firm concentration ratio, written CR4, which adds the shares of the top four firms; CR8 does the same for the top eight. In the four-firm example above, CR4 is 100 per cent, while in the ten-equal-firm market it is 40 per cent. As a rough convention, a CR4 above about 60 per cent is read as a sign of an oligopoly, and a low ratio as a sign of a competitive industry. Its weakness is that it ignores how shares are spread within the top group and says nothing about the rest of the market. A market where one firm holds 70 per cent and three others hold 10 per cent each has the same CR4 as one with four firms at 25 per cent, yet the HHI is 5,200 in the first case and 2,500 in the second. The HHI therefore usually gives a fuller picture of market power.
Concentration in banking and payments
Banking regulators and competition authorities apply the HHI to local deposit markets when reviewing bank mergers, because many households and small firms still bank close to home. The index is also used to describe concentration among card networks, payment processors and clearing services, where network effects tend to push markets towards a few large players. High concentration in these markets matters for the fees merchants pay and for how quickly new payment methods can enter.
Limitations
The HHI is only as good as the market definition behind it. Draw the market too widely and concentration looks low; draw it too narrowly and it looks high. Market shares are a snapshot and can overstate power in markets where entry is easy or where buyers switch quickly, and understate it where a firm controls an essential input. The index also says nothing directly about prices or profits, which is why it is used as a first screen within broader analysis of competition.
External links
Ref 1100001682