Economic profit is the profit that remains after every cost of doing business has been deducted, including the cost of the capital tied up in it. Ordinary accounting profit subtracts wages, materials, interest and tax, but treats the money supplied by owners as free. Economic profit also subtracts what that money could have earned elsewhere. A business makes an economic profit only when it earns more than its capital providers require.
The idea has two closely related uses. In economic theory it is revenue less all explicit and implicit costs, and it explains why firms enter and leave industries. In corporate finance it is a performance measure calculated from the financial statements, widely known under the trade name economic value added, or EVA, and also called residual income.
Economic profit in economic theory
Economists divide costs into explicit costs, which involve a payment, and implicit costs, which are the value of resources the owner already holds and uses in the business. Implicit costs are a form of opportunity cost: the salary the owner could earn in other work, and the return the owner's capital could earn in another use of similar risk.
Suppose a sole proprietor has revenue of $200,000 and pays out $140,000 in expenses. Accounting profit is $60,000. If the owner gave up a $50,000 salary to run the business and has invested savings that would otherwise earn $5,000 a year, implicit costs are $55,000 and economic profit is dollars.
The accounting profit that just covers implicit costs is called normal profit, and at that point economic profit is zero. In the model of perfect competition, positive economic profit attracts new firms, which pushes prices down until it disappears, and losses drive firms out until it returns to zero. Lasting economic profit therefore signals some obstacle to competition, such as barriers to entry or a monopoly.
Formula in corporate finance
For a company, the calculation is:
- is net operating profit after tax: operating profit less the tax that would be due on it, before any deduction for interest.
- is the weighted average cost of capital, the blended return required by lenders and shareholders.
- is the debt and equity funding employed in operations, usually measured at the start of the period or as an average.
The product of the last two terms is the capital charge. The same result can be written as a spread:
where ROIC, the return on invested capital, is NOPAT divided by invested capital.
Worked example
A company has invested capital of $1,000 million, earns NOPAT of $150 million and has a weighted average cost of capital of 9 percent. The capital charge is million dollars, and economic profit is million dollars. Using the second form, ROIC is 15 percent, the spread over the cost of capital is 6 percentage points, and again gives $60 million.
If the same company earned NOPAT of only $70 million, it would still report a positive accounting profit, but its economic profit would be million dollars. In that year it used its investors' money less productively than they could have used it themselves.
Use in valuation and management
The measure became prominent in the 1990s, when the consulting firm Stern Stewart promoted EVA as a basis for managing companies and paying executives. The reasoning was that managers judged on net income or earnings per share have an incentive to grow by using more capital, even at poor returns, whereas a capital charge makes them treat capital as costly. The approach is associated with the pursuit of shareholder value.
In valuation, the worth of a business can be expressed as its invested capital plus the present value of its expected future economic profits. This is mathematically equivalent to a discounted cash flow valuation, but it shows more plainly where value comes from: only returns above the cost of capital add to it. Growth at a return equal to the cost of capital adds nothing, and growth below it destroys value. Market multiples such as enterprise value to invested capital can be read as the market's estimate of that future stream. A company expected to sustain economic profits for a long time is said to have an economic moat.
Limitations
- Estimating the cost of capital. The cost of equity cannot be observed and must be estimated from a model, and small changes in it move the result substantially.
- Accounting distortions. Invested capital is taken from the balance sheet at historical cost. Old, heavily depreciated assets make returns look high, and spending on research or brands is expensed instead of being counted as capital. Practitioners apply many adjustments, which reduces comparability.
- Bias against investment. A new project adds capital at once and profit only later, so the measure can discourage sound long-term investment if applied one year at a time.
- Size effects. The figure is in money terms, so large companies show larger amounts. Comparisons across firms need the spread or a ratio.
For banks and insurers, debt is part of the operating business and not simply a source of funding, so the measure is recast on an equity basis, as net income less a charge for book value of equity times the required rate of return.