General average is a principle of maritime law under which an extraordinary sacrifice or expense, made intentionally and reasonably to save a ship and its cargo from a common danger, is shared by everyone with property at stake in the voyage. If cargo is thrown overboard to stop a vessel capsizing, or a master orders a costly tow to a port of refuge after an engine fire, the owner of the lost goods or the party that paid the bill does not bear the cost alone. The ship, cargo and freight at risk all contribute in proportion to value.
The idea is usually traced to the Rhodian sea law on jettison, which Roman jurists recorded and the Digest of Justinian preserved. Today it is applied almost everywhere through the York-Antwerp Rules, a private set of rules maintained by the Comite Maritime International (CMI) and incorporated by reference into most bills of lading and charterparties. It is distinct from particular average, a partial loss that falls on one interest alone, which is covered in Marine Insurance Losses.
What counts as a general average act
A general average act needs several elements. There must be a real peril threatening the whole common maritime adventure, not just one cargo owner or the ship alone. The sacrifice or expenditure must be extraordinary, beyond what the shipowner already owes under the contract of carriage. It must be intentional and reasonable, and it must be made for the common safety.
Typical examples include:
- Jettison. Cargo or ship equipment deliberately thrown overboard to lighten a vessel in danger.
- Damage from firefighting. Water or foam that ruins sound cargo while the crew puts out a fire in another hold.
- Port of refuge costs. Entering a port to make the vessel safe, with the costs of discharging, storing and reloading cargo and some of the crew wages and fuel used while there.
- Salvage. Payments to salvors who rescue ship and cargo together, commonly treated as general average.
In English law the same concept is written into the Marine Insurance Act 1906, which defines a general average loss and gives the person who suffers it a right of rateable contribution from the other interested parties. Marine insurance policies then indemnify the insured for both the sacrifice and the contribution.
How contributions are calculated
After the voyage an average adjuster appointed by the shipowner collects the evidence and prepares an adjustment. The adjuster values each contributing interest at the place and time the adventure ends, adds back any amounts made good as general average, and divides the allowable loss in proportion. The basic formula is:
- is the contribution owed by interest (the ship, a cargo lot or the freight at risk).
- is the total loss and expense allowed in general average.
- is the contributory value of interest .
- is the sum of the contributory values of all interests.
As an example, take a ship worth 20 million, cargo lot A worth 6 million and cargo lot B worth 4 million, giving total contributory values of 30 million. If allowable general average comes to 1.5 million, the rate is 1.5 divided by 30, or 5 per cent. The ship contributes 1 million, cargo A 300,000 and cargo B 200,000. If cargo B was jettisoned, its owner is credited with its lost value and receives a net payment from the others.
Security and the release of cargo
Adjustments can take years, so the shipowner needs security before handing the goods over. The shipowner has a possessory lien on the cargo for general average contributions and may refuse delivery until security is given. Each consignee normally signs an average bond, promising to pay its share once the adjustment is final, and supplies either a cash deposit or a general average guarantee. Where the cargo is insured, the cargo insurer usually gives that guarantee.
Uninsured cargo owners may have to lodge a large cash deposit to get their goods released, so traders buying on terms such as Cost, Insurance and Freight (CIF) check that cover is in place and that the policy follows the Institute Cargo Clauses, all of which cover general average and salvage charges. Once the insurer pays, it takes over the cargo owner's rights through subrogation.
The York-Antwerp Rules and modern practice
The York-Antwerp Rules grew out of nineteenth-century efforts to harmonise national practice and were first adopted in 1890. The CMI has revised them several times; the 1994 and 2016 versions are the ones most often seen in contracts, and parties choose the version in their bill of lading or charterparty. They combine general principles with numbered rules on specific losses, under a Rule Paramount requiring that any sacrifice or expense be reasonably made or incurred.
On large container ships a single casualty can involve thousands of cargo interests, each of which must post security before collecting its containers, and the 2021 grounding of the Ever Given in the Suez Canal led its owner to declare general average. Critics say the system is slow and costly for small cargo claims; supporters reply that it fairly spreads risk across the voyage. Whether the shipowner's own fault, such as an unseaworthy vessel, defeats its claim is decided under the contract of carriage and rules such as the Hague-Visby Rules. Liabilities that fall outside general average, such as pollution and wreck removal, are usually handled by P&I insurance.
External links
Ref 1170000322