Greenwashing is the practice of making a company, product, service or investment appear more environmentally sound than it is. It ranges from outright false statements to claims that are vague, selective or impossible to verify. The word is modelled on whitewashing and is generally credited to the environmentalist Jay Westerveld, who used it in 1986 to describe hotels that promoted towel reuse as a green measure while doing little else to reduce their impact.
In finance the term is applied most often to funds and securities marketed as sustainable. The growth of ESG investing created a commercial incentive to attach a green label to products, and regulators in the United States, the European Union and the United Kingdom now treat misleading sustainability claims as a matter of investor protection. Related words have followed: social washing for overstated social benefits, and greenhushing for firms that stay silent about their environmental goals to avoid scrutiny.
Common forms
- Vague language. Words such as eco-friendly, natural or sustainable are used without a definition or a measurable standard.
- Selective disclosure. One favourable attribute is promoted while larger harms go unmentioned, for instance a recyclable package around a product with a heavy carbon footprint.
- Unsupported targets. A net zero pledge is announced with no interim milestones, funding or plan, or relies largely on low-quality offsets.
- Misleading labels and imagery. Packaging, logos or self-made certificates suggest independent endorsement that does not exist.
- Irrelevant claims. A product is advertised as free of a substance that is already banned by law.
Greenwashing in investment products
An ESG fund can mislead in several ways. Its name may suggest a focus that its holdings do not reflect. Its documents may describe a research process, such as ESG integration or exclusionary screening, that portfolio managers do not in fact apply to every holding. It may claim real-world impact when it simply holds shares bought in the secondary market. The problem is made harder by the lack of a single definition of sustainable: an ESG score from one provider often disagrees with the score from another, so a fund can cite whichever is most flattering.
Debt markets face a similar issue. Proceeds from green bonds are meant to finance eligible projects, and voluntary standards such as the Green Bond Principles call for external review and reporting on the use of proceeds. Sustainability-linked bonds, whose coupon depends on the issuer meeting a target, have been criticised where the targets were easy to reach. In impact investing, the equivalent concern is sometimes called impact washing.
Regulation and standards
The European Union has gone furthest in writing rules. Its Sustainable Finance Disclosure Regulation, which began to apply in 2021, requires fund managers to disclose how sustainability is taken into account and sorts products by the strength of their claims. The EU Taxonomy defines which economic activities may be described as environmentally sustainable, and the European Securities and Markets Authority has issued guidelines on the use of sustainability-related terms in fund names.
In the United Kingdom, the Financial Conduct Authority introduced an anti-greenwashing rule in 2024 requiring that sustainability claims by authorised firms be fair, clear and not misleading, alongside a set of investment labels. Consumer and advertising regulators police product claims separately. In the United States, the Securities and Exchange Commission amended its fund names rule in 2023 so that a fund whose name suggests an ESG focus must invest at least 80 percent of its assets accordingly, and the Federal Trade Commission publishes guidance on environmental marketing claims.
Reporting standards aim to reduce the room for selective disclosure. The Global Reporting Initiative and the standards developed by the Sustainability Accounting Standards Board set out what companies should measure, including their greenhouse gas emissions.
Enforcement and consequences
Enforcement has mostly relied on existing rules against misleading statements. The SEC has fined several asset managers for describing ESG procedures that were not followed in practice. The largest such penalty to date, $19 million, was imposed in 2023 on the US arm of DWS, the asset manager controlled by Deutsche Bank, whose offices had been searched by German authorities the previous year. Companies outside finance have faced advertising bans, consumer lawsuits and shareholder claims over environmental statements.
Beyond fines, the consequences include damage to reputation, redemptions from funds, and the cost of renaming or reclassifying products. Many European funds were moved to a less demanding disclosure category or dropped sustainability terms from their names as the rules tightened.
Difficulties and criticism
Critics of the regulatory approach note that greenwashing is hard to define while sustainability itself remains contested. A fund that holds oil companies in order to press them to change may be accused of greenwashing by one observer and praised for stewardship by another. Detailed rules also raise costs and can encourage greenhushing, which leaves investors with less information. Supporters respond that clear labels and audited data are the only way for the market to distinguish substantive claims from marketing.