Home / Wiki / E / ESG Score

ESG Score

Investment and Capital MarketsUpdated 16 Nov 2026

An ESG score is a rating that summarizes, in a number or a letter grade, how a company performs on environmental, social and governance matters. Scores are produced by commercial data providers and sold mainly to asset managers, who use them to select and weight holdings, build indices and report on portfolios. They are the basic data input of ESG investing.

The term is also written ESG rating. Despite the resemblance, an ESG score is not comparable to a credit rating. Credit ratings from different agencies measure the same thing, the likelihood of default, and largely agree. ESG scores from different providers measure different things in different ways and frequently disagree about the same company.

01

What a score measures

Providers start from a list of issues under each of the three pillars. Environmental issues include greenhouse gas emissions, energy and water use, pollution and waste. Social issues include labour practices, health and safety, product safety, data privacy and topics such as diversity and inclusion. Governance issues include the independence of the board of directors, executive pay, shareholder rights, audit quality and business conduct, sometimes grouped as ethical leadership.

Two different questions can be asked of these issues, and providers do not all ask the same one. Most scores sold to investors measure financial materiality: how exposed the company's value is to ESG risks and how well it manages them. Others try to measure the company's effect on the environment and society, whatever the consequence for its shareholders. A high score of the first kind does not mean that a company is good for the world. It means that the rater judges its ESG risks to be well controlled.

02

How scores are constructed

The usual process has four steps. The provider collects data from company reports, regulatory filings, questionnaires, news sources and third-party databases, and estimates figures that companies do not disclose. It converts the data into indicators for each issue. It weights the issues, usually by industry, so that emissions count heavily for a utility and data security for a bank. Finally it combines the weighted indicators into pillar scores and an overall score.

Design choices differ at each step. Some scores are relative, ranking a company against others in its industry, so the best oil producer may outscore an average software firm. Others are absolute measures of unmanaged risk on a common scale. Scales run from letter grades to scores out of 100, and on some scales a lower number is better. Many providers add a separate controversies assessment based on news of incidents, fines and lawsuits. Frameworks such as those of the Sustainability Accounting Standards Board guide the choice of issues by industry.

03

How investors use them

  • Screening. Funds exclude companies below a threshold, or apply exclusionary screening on particular issues.
  • Tilting and index construction. A benchmark index is reweighted towards higher-scoring companies, and the result is tracked by an ESG fund.
  • Integration. Analysts feed scores and the underlying data into valuation and risk models, a practice called ESG integration.
  • Engagement and voting. Managers use weak scores to choose companies for dialogue and to guide proxy voting.

Companies in turn watch their scores, since inclusion in ESG indices affects demand for their shares and some loans and bonds tie the interest rate to sustainability measures.

04

Why scores disagree

The low agreement between providers is the best-documented feature of ESG scores. A widely cited study by Florian Berg, Julian Kölbel and Roberto Rigobon, published in 2022, compared six major raters and found an average correlation between their scores of roughly 0.5, far below the near-perfect agreement of credit ratings. The authors traced the divergence to three sources: raters cover different sets of issues, they measure the same issue with different indicators, and they weight issues differently. Differences in measurement accounted for the largest share.

The practical consequence is that a company can sit in the top group with one provider and the bottom group with another, and a fund's ESG profile depends heavily on which provider its manager uses.

05

Criticism

Beyond divergence, several criticisms recur. Larger companies tend to score higher, partly because they have the resources to publish more data and answer questionnaires, so scores may reward disclosure as much as conduct. Combining unrelated issues into one figure lets strength on one offset weakness on another, which can hide a serious failing. Methodologies change, and researchers have found cases of past scores being rewritten, which complicates any test of whether scores predict returns.

The link with investment performance is unsettled. Studies reach conflicting conclusions, in part because the scores themselves differ. Critics also argue that scores give false precision and make greenwashing easier, since a product can be labelled sustainable on the strength of ratings that measure financial risk and not real-world impact.

06

Regulation

ESG rating providers were long unregulated. The International Organization of Securities Commissions recommended in 2021 that regulators pay closer attention to them, and several jurisdictions have since acted. The European Union adopted a regulation in 2024 that requires providers operating there to be authorized and supervised by its securities markets authority and to disclose their methods and manage conflicts of interest. The United Kingdom, Japan, India and others have introduced rules or codes of conduct of their own.

Last updated 16 Nov 2026