A carbon footprint is the total quantity of greenhouse gases released into the atmosphere as a result of the activities of a person, a household, a product, an organization, an event or a country. It covers emissions produced directly, such as fuel burned in a vehicle, and indirectly, such as the electricity used and the goods bought. The result is stated in mass of carbon dioxide equivalent, usually tonnes per year.
The measure is the basic unit of accounting in efforts to limit climate change. Companies report their footprints to regulators and investors, governments compile national inventories under the Paris Agreement, and fund managers calculate the footprint of portfolios as part of ESG investing. The term grew out of the idea of the ecological footprint developed in the 1990s and was spread widely in the 2000s, in part by an oil company's advertising campaign that invited individuals to calculate their own.
Carbon dioxide equivalent
Carbon dioxide is the main greenhouse gas from human activity, but not the only one. Methane, nitrous oxide and several industrial gases also trap heat, each to a different degree and for a different length of time. To add them together, each is converted to the amount of carbon dioxide that would cause the same warming over a set period, normally 100 years, using a factor called global warming potential. A tonne of methane counts as roughly 28 to 30 tonnes of carbon dioxide equivalent on that basis.
Scopes of emissions
For organizations, the most widely used standard is the Greenhouse Gas Protocol, which divides emissions into three scopes:
- Scope 1. Direct emissions from sources the organization owns or controls, such as boilers, furnaces, vehicles and industrial processes.
- Scope 2. Indirect emissions from the generation of electricity, steam, heat or cooling that the organization buys.
- Scope 3. All other indirect emissions in the value chain. These include purchased goods and services, business travel, transport, waste, and the use and disposal of the products sold. For banks and investors they include the emissions of the companies and projects they finance.
For most businesses Scope 3 is by far the largest part and the hardest to measure, since it depends on data from suppliers and customers.
Calculation
Emissions are rarely measured directly. They are estimated by multiplying a measure of activity by a published factor:
- is the emissions, in kilograms or tonnes of carbon dioxide equivalent.
- is the activity data, such as kilowatt-hours of electricity, litres of fuel, kilometres travelled or money spent.
- is the emission factor, the emissions per unit of that activity.
An office that uses 10,000 kilowatt-hours of electricity in a year, on a grid with a factor of 0.4 kilograms per kilowatt-hour, has Scope 2 emissions of kilograms, or 4 tonnes. If it also burns 2,000 litres of heating oil at 2.7 kilograms per litre, that adds kilograms of Scope 1 emissions, for a total of 9.4 tonnes before Scope 3.
The footprint of a product is worked out by life cycle assessment, which adds up emissions from raw materials, manufacture, transport, use and disposal. National footprints can be stated on a territorial basis, counting emissions within the country's borders, or on a consumption basis, which adds emissions from imported goods and subtracts those from exports.
Use in finance
Investors use footprints to compare companies and to measure the exposure of portfolios to climate policy. Common measures divide a company's emissions by its revenue to give carbon intensity, or allocate emissions to investors in proportion to their share of the company's value, giving financed emissions. The Task Force on Climate-related Financial Disclosures recommended weighted average carbon intensity as a standard portfolio figure, and its framework has since been taken up in international sustainability reporting standards.
A high footprint signals exposure to transition risk: the possibility that a carbon tax, emissions trading or tighter regulation will raise costs or strand assets. Funds practising sustainable investing may set targets to cut portfolio emissions over time, and investor coalitions such as Climate Action 100+ press the largest emitters to set reduction plans. Footprint data also determine eligibility for green bonds and the targets in sustainability-linked debt.
Reducing and offsetting
An organization can lower its footprint by using less energy, switching to renewable energy, changing materials and processes, and choosing lower-emission suppliers. Purchased electricity can be matched with a renewable energy certificate. Remaining emissions are sometimes balanced by buying carbon credits, each representing a tonne avoided or removed elsewhere, for example through carbon sequestration in forests. Some credits are now issued as tokenized carbon credits.
Criticism and limitations
- Data quality. Much of Scope 3 is estimated from industry averages or spending, so reported figures carry wide margins of error and are hard to compare between companies.
- Double counting. One company's Scope 1 is another's Scope 2 or 3, so footprints cannot simply be added across a portfolio or an economy.
- Backward-looking. A footprint describes past emissions. It does not show whether a company is investing to cut them, and selling a polluting asset lowers the seller's footprint without lowering emissions.
- Offsets. The quality of carbon credits varies, and investigations have found many that did not deliver the reductions claimed.
- Individual focus. Critics argue that stress on personal footprints shifts attention from the energy system and from producers to consumers.