A clean bill of lading is a bill of lading that carries no clause or notation stating that the goods or their packaging were damaged, defective or short when the carrier took them over. By issuing it, the carrier records that the cargo was received in apparent good order and condition. Buyers, banks and lenders treat a clean bill as basic evidence that the seller handed over sound goods, and most letters of credit and sale contracts call for one.
The opposite is a foul bill of lading, also called a claused or dirty bill, which bears a remark such as "three cartons torn" or "drums leaking". A clean bill is not a statement about quality: the carrier only records what an ordinary outward inspection shows. For documentary credits the requirement comes from the Uniform Customs and Practice for Documentary Credits (UCP 600), published by the International Chamber of Commerce, which says that a bank will accept only a clean transport document.
What makes a bill of lading clean
The test is whether a clause or notation expressly declares a defective condition of the goods or their packaging. The word "clean" does not have to appear on the document, and a bill is not made foul merely because that word has been struck out. What matters is the wording that the carrier or its agent has added, usually stamped or typed over the printed form when the goods are tallied at the port or terminal.
Several kinds of wording are generally treated as compatible with a clean bill:
- Standard printed terms. Clauses such as "said to contain" or "shipper's load, stow and count" limit what the carrier vouches for when it cannot see inside a sealed container; they do not declare a defect.
- Cautious statements. A remark that packaging "may not be sufficient" for the voyage is usually read as a warning, whereas a remark that packaging "is not sufficient" declares a defect and makes the bill foul.
- Remarks on other matters. Notes about the vessel, freight or the port do not affect cleanliness, because the test concerns only the goods and their packing.
Clean bills under letters of credit
Under a letter of credit, the clean requirement applies to every kind of transport document, not only marine bills, so sea waybills, air waybills and multimodal documents are examined the same way. The credit often asks for a "clean on board" bill, combining this rule with the need for an on-board notation showing that the goods were actually loaded. Even then, UCP 600 says the word "clean" need not appear.
Examining banks apply UCP 600 together with ISBP 821, the ICC's guide to international standard banking practice. A bill bearing a clause that expressly declares damage is a discrepancy, so the presentation is not a complying presentation and the issuing bank may refuse to pay. The applicant can still choose to waive the discrepancy, but the beneficiary then depends on the applicant's goodwill rather than on the bank's undertaking.
Legal effect for carriers and holders
Under the Hague-Visby Rules, which govern many ocean carriage contracts, a bill of lading is prima facie evidence that the carrier received the goods as described. Once the bill has been transferred to a third party acting in good faith, the carrier cannot prove otherwise. This is why a clean bill matters so much to the holder of a negotiable bill of lading: a buyer or bank that pays against it relies on the carrier's statement, and if the goods turn out to have been damaged before loading, the carrier may be liable for the misstatement.
Conversely, a foul clause shifts the risk back onto the shipper. A buyer receiving a claused bill has early warning that the cargo may be defective and can refuse documents or reserve its rights under the sale contract.
Letters of indemnity and other risks
A shipper whose goods are slightly damaged may ask the carrier to issue a clean bill anyway, in return for a letter of indemnity promising to cover any claim. English courts have refused to enforce such indemnities where the carrier knowingly issued a false clean bill, in Brown Jenkinson v Percy Dalton (1957), because the arrangement deceives the buyer and the paying bank. Protection and indemnity clubs, which provide P&I insurance to shipowners, generally warn members that cover may not respond to claims arising from knowingly misdated or misdescribed bills.
False statements about goods on shipping documents are also a recognised warning sign of trade-based money laundering and documentary fraud, so banks compare the bill with the commercial invoice, packing list and any inspection certificate rather than relying on the clean notation alone.
Clean bills in sale contracts and insurance
In sales on CIF or CFR terms, the seller performs largely by tendering documents, and buyers usually stipulate a clean bill so that they can reject a tender showing defective cargo. Cargo insurers and marine insurance adjusters also use the bill as evidence of the condition of the goods at loading when deciding whether a loss happened in transit. The same rules carry over to an electronic bill of lading, where the clean or claused status is recorded in the data rather than on paper.
External links
Ref 1310000358