A complying presentation is a delivery of documents under a letter of credit that conforms to three things at once: the terms and conditions of the credit itself, the applicable provisions of the Uniform Customs and Practice for Documentary Credits (UCP 600), and international standard banking practice. It is the central idea of documentary credit law, because it is the event that turns a bank's conditional undertaking into a definite obligation to pay the beneficiary. Under UCP 600 the word presentation means both the act of delivering documents under a credit and the documents delivered.
The phrase is defined in UCP 600, the International Chamber of Commerce (ICC) rules that govern most commercial credits, and a parallel concept appears in the Uniform Rules for Demand Guarantees (URDG 758), where it applies to a demand and its supporting documents. It is closely linked to the independence principle: banks deal with documents and not with the goods, services or performance to which the documents relate, so compliance is judged on the paper presented and nothing else.
What a presentation must match
The first test is the credit. Every document the credit calls for must be presented, each must carry the data the credit requires, and the presentation must arrive at the right place before the expiry date and within the presentation period after shipment. Typical requirements include a commercial invoice, a bill of lading or other transport document, an insurance document and certificates such as a certificate of origin.
The second test is the rules. UCP 600 sets default standards for many documents, for example what a transport document must show to evidence shipment on board, or what an insurance document must cover, which apply unless the credit says otherwise. The third test is practice. The ICC publishes the International Standard Banking Practice (ISBP) to describe how document checkers around the world interpret the rules, covering matters such as misspellings, abbreviations, signatures and dates.
How banks examine documents
A nominated bank, any confirming bank and the issuing bank each examine the presentation to decide, on the basis of the documents alone, whether they appear on their face to comply. Under UCP 600 each bank has a maximum of five banking days following the day of presentation to make that determination. The process is described in more detail under examination of documents. If the presentation complies, the issuing bank must honour the credit by paying at sight, incurring a deferred payment undertaking or accepting a draft, depending on how the credit is available.
Several principles from UCP 600 shape the examination:
- Data need not be identical across documents. Information in a document, read in context with the credit and the other documents, must not conflict with them, but it does not have to be a mirror image.
- Goods descriptions are stricter on the invoice. The description of the goods in the commercial invoice must correspond with the description in the credit, while other documents may describe the goods in general terms.
- Non-documentary conditions are disregarded. A condition in the credit that does not specify a document to show compliance is treated as not stated, which is why a non-documentary condition gives the applicant little protection.
Why compliance triggers payment
When the issuing bank determines that a presentation is complying, it must honour, meaning pay at sight, incur a deferred payment undertaking and pay at maturity, or accept a draft and pay it at maturity, depending on how the credit is available. A confirming bank that receives a complying presentation must likewise honour or negotiate and forward the documents. A nominated bank that has paid against a complying presentation is entitled to reimbursement from the issuing bank. This makes a credit a reliable payment instrument: the seller knows in advance what it must show to be paid, and the bank cannot refuse for reasons outside the documents, such as a dispute about the quality of the goods.
If the presentation does not comply, the bank may refuse it. A refusal must be made by a single notice that states all the discrepancies, given without delay and within the examination period. A bank that fails to give a proper notice of refusal is generally precluded from claiming that the documents did not comply. The bank may also approach the applicant for a waiver of the discrepancies, but it is not obliged to do so.
Discrepancies in practice
Industry surveys have long reported that a large share of first presentations under letters of credit contain at least one discrepancy, which shows how demanding the standard is. Common faults include late shipment, late presentation, inconsistent data between invoice and transport document, missing signatures or endorsements, and insurance cover that starts after the shipment date. Applicants often waive minor discrepancies, but each one gives the issuing bank the right to refuse and can delay payment, add a discrepancy fee, or leave the seller relying on the buyer's goodwill.
Exporters reduce the risk by checking the credit carefully on receipt, asking for an amendment to any term that cannot be met, and preparing documents from a single source of data. Where documents are presented electronically under the eUCP, the same standard applies to electronic records.
Guarantees and standby credits
The idea carries over to independent undertakings. Under URDG 758, a demand under a demand guarantee must be a complying demand supported by any documents the guarantee requires, judged against the guarantee, the rules and international standard demand guarantee practice. Standby letters of credit governed by ISP98 use their own examination standards, which are generally less exacting about the form of documents than UCP 600 but still require the presentation to match the terms of the standby.
External links
Ref 1310000369