Chapter 11 bankruptcy is the reorganisation procedure set out in Chapter 11 of the US Bankruptcy Code. It lets a financially distressed company, partnership or, less often, individual keep operating while it renegotiates its obligations under the supervision of a federal bankruptcy court. The aim is to preserve the value of a going concern, which is usually higher than what creditors would recover if the assets were sold off piecemeal.
Chapter 11 is distinct from Chapter 7 bankruptcy, in which a trustee closes the business and liquidates its assets, and from Chapter 13 bankruptcy, a repayment plan for individuals with regular income. A case can start with a voluntary petition by the debtor or, less commonly, an involuntary petition by creditors, and a Chapter 11 case can be converted to Chapter 7 if reorganisation fails.
Debtor in possession and the automatic stay
When a Chapter 11 case is filed, existing management normally stays in control as the debtor in possession, with most of the powers and duties of a trustee. A separate trustee is appointed only for cause, such as fraud or gross mismanagement. The filing triggers the automatic stay under section 362, which halts lawsuits, collection efforts, foreclosures and the enforcement of liens against the debtor and its property. Secured creditors can ask the court to lift the stay or to grant adequate protection if their collateral is losing value; their position is described further under secured lenders in US bankruptcy.
An official committee of unsecured creditors is usually appointed to represent that group, investigate the debtor and negotiate the plan. The debtor can also pursue avoidance claims to recover certain payments made before the filing, covered under avoidance actions and equitable subordination.
Financing the case
A company in Chapter 11 needs cash to pay staff and suppliers. With court approval it can use cash that is collateral for existing loans and can borrow new money through debtor-in-possession (DIP) financing. Because lending to a bankrupt company is risky, the Code allows the court to give DIP lenders priority over other administrative claims and, where existing lienholders are adequately protected, liens that rank ahead of them. DIP loans are often provided by the existing senior lenders and may roll up part of their pre-filing debt.
Plan of Reorganization
The plan of reorganization is the document that sets out how each claim and interest will be treated. Claims are grouped into classes of substantially similar claims, such as secured lenders, trade creditors, bondholders and equity, a process discussed under creditor class composition. After the court approves a disclosure statement, impaired classes vote. A class accepts if creditors holding at least two-thirds in amount and more than half in number of the claims that vote are in favour.
To confirm the plan, the court must find that it is feasible, that each dissenting creditor receives at least what it would get in a Chapter 7 liquidation (the best interests test), and that at least one impaired class has accepted. If some classes reject, the court can still confirm through cramdown, provided the plan does not discriminate unfairly and is fair and equitable, which for unsecured classes means the absolute priority rule: no junior class may keep anything unless the dissenting senior class is paid in full. Plans often swap debt for new shares through a debt-for-equity swap.
Section 363 sales
Instead of reorganising, a debtor may sell all or part of its business under section 363 of the Code, which lets the court approve a sale outside a plan, free and clear of liens, with the liens attaching to the proceeds. Secured lenders can usually credit bid, offering the amount of their debt instead of cash.
Stalking Horse Bid
A stalking horse bid is the first offer the debtor accepts for its assets before an auction in a section 363 sale. The stalking horse bidder does the due diligence and negotiates the purchase agreement, and its price becomes the floor that rival bidders must beat. In return for setting that floor and the risk of being outbid, the court may approve bid protections: a break-up fee, usually a small percentage of the price, and reimbursement of expenses if another bidder wins. Bidding procedures also set minimum overbid increments and deadlines. Courts scrutinise these protections so that they encourage, rather than chill, competitive bidding, and an existing lender sometimes acts as stalking horse through a credit bid.
Prepackaged cases and Subchapter V
To save time and cost, many companies agree terms with key creditors before filing. In a prepackaged case, votes are solicited before the petition; in a pre-negotiated case, a restructuring support agreement commits creditors to support a plan that is filed with the case. Either can shorten a Chapter 11 case from many months to a few weeks.
Subchapter V, added by the Small Business Reorganization Act of 2019 and in force since February 2020, is a streamlined version for small businesses whose debts fall under a statutory limit. It has no creditors' committee by default, appoints a standing trustee to help the process along, removes the absolute priority rule for confirming a plan, and allows owners to keep their equity if the plan commits projected disposable income to creditors for three to five years.
Criticism
Chapter 11 is praised for preserving businesses and jobs, and its features have influenced reforms abroad, including the UK restructuring plan with its cross-class cramdown. Critics point to high professional fees in large cases, forum shopping between court districts, the use of the procedure by solvent companies to manage mass tort liabilities, and repeat filings by companies that emerge with too much debt.
External links
Ref 1210000669