A debt-for-equity swap is a transaction in which a borrower's lenders give up some or all of their claims and receive an ownership interest in the borrower in return. The debt is cancelled and new shares are issued to the former lenders. It is also called a debt-to-equity conversion. The company's obligations and interest bill fall, its equity rises, and its existing owners are left with a smaller share.
The swap is one of the main tools of debt restructuring for a company that cannot service its borrowings but has a business worth preserving. It is used in a negotiated corporate restructuring, in court-supervised reorganizations, in the rescue of banks, and occasionally by governments dealing with foreign debt.
How the swap works
The parties agree how much debt will be exchanged and at what price in shares. The share of the company the lenders end up with follows from the number of new shares:
where the number of new shares is:
- is the number of shares outstanding before the swap.
- is the number of shares issued to the lenders.
- The conversion price is the amount of debt cancelled for each new share.
In a distressed case the conversion price is a matter of negotiation, since the market price of the shares may be close to zero. It depends on what the business is judged to be worth and on what each side would receive if the company were liquidated instead.
Worked example
A company owes 500 million dollars at 8 percent interest and has 100 million shares outstanding. It cannot meet the annual interest of million dollars. Lenders agree to exchange 200 million dollars of debt at a conversion price of 2 dollars a share.
They receive million new shares, giving them percent of the company. Existing shareholders fall from 100 percent to 50 percent. Debt drops to 300 million dollars and annual interest to million dollars, a saving of 16 million dollars a year.
Why each side agrees
For the company, the swap removes fixed payments it cannot afford and avoids or shortens insolvency proceedings. It is a direct way of deleveraging without having to find cash.
For a creditor, shares in a viable company with less debt may be worth more than the amount it would recover from a forced sale of assets. The lender exchanges a fixed claim that will not be paid in full for a variable one that may regain value. Some investors buy distressed debt at a discount with the specific aim of converting it and taking control.
Existing shareholders accept heavy dilution because the alternative is usually worse. In a liquidation they rank last and often receive nothing. Lenders higher in the order of priority, such as secured banks, may be repaid or keep their loans, while the class of debt whose value runs out partway becomes the new owner.
Settings in which swaps occur
- Out-of-court agreements. Lenders consent individually or through an exchange offer to bondholders. A minority may refuse in the hope of being paid in full.
- Court reorganizations. In a United States Chapter 11 case and similar procedures elsewhere, a plan approved by the required majorities and the court can impose the swap on all members of a class, as part of bankruptcy law.
- Banks. Rules adopted after the 2008 crisis let authorities convert certain bank debt into shares in a bail-in. A contingent convertible bond builds the conversion into the contract from the start.
- Sovereign debt. In the 1980s several indebted countries let foreign lenders exchange loans for local currency to be invested in domestic companies. Chile ran one of the best-known programs.
Accounting and tax
In the borrower's accounts the cancelled liability is removed and shareholders' equity increases. Under international standards the new shares are measured at fair value, and any difference from the carrying amount of the debt is recognized in profit or loss. For lenders, the shares received are recorded at fair value, normally with a loss against the original loan. Tax law in many countries treats forgiven debt as income of the borrower, subject to exceptions for insolvent companies, and a change of ownership can limit the use of past tax losses.
Criticism and risks
A swap repairs the balance sheet but not the business. If the cause of distress is a failing product or an outdated cost base, the company may return to difficulty, and former lenders then hold shares worth less than the debt they gave up. Banks may be reluctant or unsuited owners of industrial companies, and regulators limit the shareholdings they may keep. Disputes over valuation are frequent, because the conversion price decides how value is divided between classes of investors.