Avoidance actions and equitable subordination are the powers that the US Bankruptcy Code gives a bankruptcy estate to undo transactions that unfairly favoured some creditors before a filing, or to demote a creditor that behaved inequitably. They are used by a trustee in a Chapter 7 liquidation, by a debtor in possession or creditors' committee in a Chapter 11 case, and by litigation trusts set up under a plan.
The family has two strands. Avoidance actions, chiefly preference claims and fraudulent conveyance claims, recover value that left the debtor so that it can be shared among all creditors; recovery from the transferee follows under a separate section of the Code. Equitable subordination does not recover money but reorders claims. Lenders meet all of these in practice: a payment received just before a filing, a guarantee given by a subsidiary or a lender's control over a troubled borrower can each be challenged.
Preferential Transfer
A preferential transfer, also called a preference or voidable preference, is a payment or other transfer of the debtor's property to a creditor, on account of an existing debt, made while the debtor was insolvent and within the preference period, that lets the creditor receive more than it would in a Chapter 7 liquidation. Section 547 of the Code allows the estate to avoid such transfers, including the grant of a lien to secure an old debt. The aim is to discourage a race to collect from a failing debtor and to treat similar creditors alike.
Section 547 also sets out defences. The most used are payments made in the ordinary course of business or on ordinary business terms, contemporaneous exchanges for new value, and subsequent new value given by the creditor after the transfer. Other defences protect purchase money security interests perfected promptly and floating liens on inventory and receivables, except to the extent the lender improved its position during the period.
Preference Period
The preference period is the look-back window before the bankruptcy petition during which transfers can be attacked as preferences. Under Section 547 it is 90 days for ordinary creditors and one year for insiders, such as directors, officers, controlling shareholders and affiliates. The longer insider period reflects the view that insiders learn of financial distress early and can arrange to be paid first.
During the 90 days before filing the debtor is presumed insolvent, so the estate does not have to prove insolvency unless the creditor rebuts the presumption; for the extended insider period it must prove it, often using a balance-sheet insolvency test. Timing rules decide when a transfer counts as made; for a security interest, the relevant date usually depends on when it was perfected, so a lien perfected late can fall inside the window even if granted earlier. Lenders monitor the window when taking new collateral or repayments from weak borrowers.
Fraudulent Conveyance (Fraudulent Transfer)
A fraudulent conveyance, now usually called a fraudulent transfer, is a transfer of property or an obligation incurred by a debtor that can be avoided to protect creditors. Section 548 covers two kinds within two years before filing. Actual fraud is a transfer made with intent to hinder, delay or defraud creditors. Constructive fraud needs no intent: it is a transfer for less than reasonably equivalent value while the debtor was insolvent, left with unreasonably small capital, or expecting to incur debts beyond its ability to pay.
Under Section 544(b) the estate can also use state law, generally the Uniform Fraudulent Transfer Act or its successor, the Uniform Voidable Transactions Act, which often allows a longer look-back, commonly four years. Lenders face this risk in a leveraged buyout (LBO), where the target's assets secure debt whose proceeds go to selling shareholders, and in upstream or cross-stream guarantees from subsidiaries that receive little direct benefit. Savings clauses that cap a guarantor's liability at the amount that would not make the transfer avoidable are a common response.
Equitable Subordination
Equitable subordination is the power of a US bankruptcy court, under Section 510(c), to rank all or part of a creditor's allowed claim below other claims because of the creditor's inequitable conduct. It does not disallow the claim; it changes its place in the distribution order, and a lien securing a subordinated claim can be transferred to the estate.
Courts commonly apply a three-part test drawn from case law: the claimant engaged in inequitable conduct, the conduct injured other creditors or gave the claimant an unfair advantage, and subordination is consistent with the Code. Insiders and controlling shareholders face the closest scrutiny. A non-insider lender is usually at risk only for serious misconduct, such as fraud or using control over a borrower to benefit itself at others' expense. The remedy is meant to repair harm, not punish, so a claim is subordinated only to the extent needed. It differs from a contractual subordination agreement and from recharacterising a loan as equity.
Comparison of the tools
| Tool | Main section | Look-back | Effect |
|---|---|---|---|
| Preferential transfer | 547 | 90 days; one year for insiders | Transfer avoided and value recovered |
| Fraudulent transfer | 548 and 544(b) | Two years federally; often longer under state law | Transfer or obligation avoided |
| Equitable subordination | 510(c) | None fixed; turns on conduct | Claim ranked below others |
All three operate alongside the protections for secured lenders in US bankruptcy and can reduce what a creditor recovers under a plan or in debtor-in-possession financing negotiations. Comparable powers exist in other countries, described generally as an avoidance transaction in insolvency.
External links
Ref 1210000667