Carrier identity and jurisdiction clauses are the printed terms of a Bill of Lading that answer two questions on which every cargo claim depends: which party is the contractual carrier, and which court or tribunal will decide a dispute. The first question arises because the document is often issued on the form of a time charterer or a liner company that does not own the ship, while the party that actually operates the vessel is the shipowner.
The clauses are read by cargo owners, insurers and banks. A buyer or a bank holding the bill as security under a Letter of Credit needs to know whom to sue if the goods are lost or damaged, and where. Three clauses do most of the work: the demise clause, the identity of carrier clause and the jurisdiction clause. Each is a term of the contract of carriage, not a rule of law, so its effect depends on its wording, on the signature on the bill and on the law that applies.
Demise Clause
A demise clause is found on the reverse of bills issued on the form of a line or a time charterer. It says that if the vessel is not owned by, or chartered by demise to, the company or line named on the front of the bill, the bill takes effect as a contract with the owner or demise charterer, and the issuing company signs only as agent. A demise (or bareboat) charter transfers possession and control of the ship to the charterer, so the demise charterer is treated like an owner. A time charterer has no such control, because the owner still provides the crew and manages the ship.
The purpose is to move liability for cargo claims from a charterer without ships or assets to the party that controls the vessel. Courts in several jurisdictions have given the clause effect, although a bill whose signature or front page points the other way may produce a different answer, and a clause that conflicts with the front of the bill can be read down. Banks also look at the signature capacity: UCP 600 expects a transport document to show the carrier and to be signed by the carrier, the master or a named agent of either.
Identity of Carrier Clause
An identity of carrier clause states in plain words who the carrier is, so that the claimant is not left guessing between owner and charterer. Typical wording says that the contract evidenced by the bill is between the merchant and the owner of the named vessel, that the owner alone is the carrier, and that anyone signing for a charterer signs as agent for the owner. Standard-form clauses of this kind were developed by industry bodies such as BIMCO for use with time charters.
The difference from the demise clause is one of technique. The demise clause is conditional and looks to the facts of ownership and charter, while the identity clause names the carrier directly. In either case a cargo claim is normally brought against the shipowner, who is usually insured through a P&I club, and the time charterer is left out of the contract. Where the two clauses appear together and point to different parties, a court has to decide which wording governs, which is a frequent source of litigation.
Jurisdiction Clause
A jurisdiction clause names the court, or an arbitration forum, that will hear disputes arising from the bill or the charter. An exclusive clause obliges the parties to use only the named forum, while a non-exclusive clause lets the named forum hear a case without barring others. The holder of a negotiable bill generally becomes bound by the clause when it takes the bill, which is why the clause matters to buyers, banks and insurers that never negotiated it.
Courts usually enforce such clauses, but some legal systems limit them for carriage of goods. The Hague-Visby Rules do not choose a forum, while the Hamburg Rules give the claimant a choice among several places, such as the port of loading or discharge. The United States Supreme Court has upheld foreign arbitration clauses in bills of lading. Within the European Union, jurisdiction agreements are generally respected under the Brussels regime. Where a charter's arbitration clause is to bind a bill holder, the bill must usually incorporate it in clear words, and the governing law and forum are often chosen together.
Ref 1060000326