Institutions, the rule of law and economic freedom are three linked ideas that economists use to explain why some countries become rich while others stay poor. Institutions are the rules that shape economic life; the rule of law describes whether those rules are applied predictably and equally; and economic freedom describes how far people are free to work, trade, save and invest within them. Together they form what economists call the "rules of the game".
The ideas are central to institutional economics, development economics and political economy. Researchers link them to economic growth, investment, the depth of financial systems and the spread of corruption. They are measured through published indices, which are widely cited but also criticised for the judgements built into them. The sections below explain each concept in turn.
Institution
In economics, an institution is a rule or norm that structures how people interact, not an organisation such as a bank. Douglass North, who shared the 1993 Nobel Memorial Prize, defined institutions as the humanly devised constraints that shape interaction, and divided them into formal rules, such as constitutions, laws and property rights, and informal ones, such as customs, codes of conduct and social norms. Organisations, such as firms and political parties, are the players who act within those rules.
Institutions matter because they set the incentives to produce, invest and innovate. Secure property rights and enforceable contracts reduce transaction costs and let strangers trade. Research by Daron Acemoglu, Simon Johnson and James Robinson argues that "inclusive" institutions, which spread power and opportunity widely, support lasting growth, while "extractive" ones, which serve a narrow elite, hold it back. Institutions also shape how firms are owned and governed.
Rule of Law
The rule of law is the principle that everyone, including the government and its officials, is bound by laws that are publicly known, stable, applied equally and enforced by independent courts. It is contrasted with rule by arbitrary decision, under which officials can seize property, ignore contracts or apply rules selectively. The British jurist A. V. Dicey gave an influential account of the idea in the nineteenth century.
For economic life, the rule of law means that property and contracts are protected, that disputes can be settled fairly, and that people can plan for the future. Lenders are more willing to extend credit when they can enforce claims against collateral, and investors commit capital when they do not fear expropriation. Weak rule of law tends to go with corruption, rent-seeking and large informal economies. It is measured by indicators such as the World Justice Project's Rule of Law Index and the rule of law component of the World Bank's Worldwide Governance Indicators.
Economic Freedom
Economic freedom is the degree to which individuals can make their own economic choices: what work to do, what to buy and sell, how to save and invest, and whether to start a business, with property protected and few arbitrary restrictions. Supporters see it as both a goal in itself and a driver of prosperity, and it is a defining feature of a market economy, in contrast to a command economy.
Two indices are widely used. The Heritage Foundation's Index of Economic Freedom, first published in 1995, scores countries on factors such as property rights, government spending, tax burden, business and trade freedom, and financial freedom. The Fraser Institute's Economic Freedom of the World report rates countries on the size of government, legal system and property rights, sound money, freedom to trade internationally and regulation. Both find that higher scores go with higher incomes, though critics note that the indices embed particular views of the right role for the state and that correlation does not prove cause.
How the three ideas relate
Institutions are the broad set of rules; the rule of law describes whether the formal rules actually bind everyone; and economic freedom describes what those rules allow private actors to do. A country can score well on one and poorly on another: some fast-growing economies have had limited political freedom but reasonably secure property rights. Weak institutions can also produce government failure or crony capitalism, in which access to markets depends on political connections rather than open rules.
External links
Ref 1100001690