An active ETF is an exchange-traded fund whose portfolio managers decide which securities to hold, rather than replicating the constituents of an index. The fund pursues a stated objective, such as beating a benchmark or producing income, but its shares are listed on a stock exchange and trade throughout the day like other ETFs.
Active ETFs bring active management into a wrapper that was built for passive investing. They compete with traditional actively managed mutual funds and with low-cost passive ETFs, and in the United States they are registered investment companies under the Investment Company Act of 1940, supervised by the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). In Europe most are UCITS funds.
How active ETFs work
An active ETF uses the same primary-market machinery as an index ETF. Authorised participants create and redeem shares in large blocks through ETF creation and redemption, usually by delivering or receiving a basket of securities. Arbitrage between the share price and the fund's net asset value keeps the two close. What differs is that the basket reflects the manager's choices rather than an index, and those choices change whenever the manager trades.
This creates a tension. Market makers need to know what the fund holds to price and hedge its shares, but many active managers do not want to reveal their trades daily, because others could copy them or trade ahead of them. How a fund resolves that tension defines its structure.
Transparent and semi-transparent structures
Active ETFs fall into broad groups based on portfolio transparency:
- Fully transparent active ETFs. These publish their complete holdings every business day, as index ETFs do. Most active ETFs in the United States use this model, which makes market making straightforward.
- Semi-transparent or non-transparent active ETFs. These disclose holdings less often, typically quarterly like a mutual fund, and give market makers a proxy portfolio, a verified intraday value or a confidential feed through an agent instead. The SEC approved several such models through exemptive relief from 2019 onwards.
Semi-transparent funds can trade at wider bid-ask spreads than transparent ones, because hedging against an approximate portfolio is less precise. Their uptake has been smaller than early forecasts suggested.
Regulation in the United States
For most of their history, US ETFs needed individual exemptive orders from the SEC to operate. The first actively managed ETFs launched in 2008 under such orders. In September 2019 the SEC adopted Rule 6c-11, the "ETF rule", which lets most transparent ETFs, active or passive, launch without a separate order, provided they meet conditions including daily disclosure of portfolio holdings on their website and written policies for the baskets they accept. The rule also allows custom baskets that differ from a pro rata slice of the portfolio, which gives active managers more flexibility. Non-transparent active ETFs fall outside the rule and still rely on exemptive relief.
Costs and tax efficiency
Active ETFs generally have a lower expense ratio than comparable active mutual funds, partly because the ETF does not keep individual shareholder accounts and has no sales loads or 12b-1 distribution fees built into most share prices. They usually cost more than index ETFs, because research and trading are more expensive than tracking an index. Investors also pay the bid-ask spread when buying and selling on an exchange.
In the United States the ETF structure can be markedly more tax-efficient. When an authorised participant redeems shares in kind, the fund can hand over low-cost-basis securities without selling them, so it realises fewer gains and makes fewer taxable capital gains distributions than a mutual fund with the same strategy. This is one of the main reasons several managers have converted active mutual funds into ETFs since 2021. The advantage is smaller in countries where funds are taxed differently.
Growth and limitations
Active ETFs were a small corner of the market for a decade after 2008. After the 2019 rule, inflows accelerated, and active funds became a large share of new US ETF launches, spanning bond strategies, option income funds, thematic equity and single-manager stock-picking. Europe has seen similar growth in active UCITS ETFs.
The structure has limits. Strategies in small or illiquid securities can be hard to fit into daily creations and redemptions, and a manager's capacity to trade without moving prices is no greater in an ETF than in a mutual fund. Daily transparency may also expose a manager's positions to front-running. And the ETF wrapper does not change the underlying evidence that many active managers fail to beat their benchmarks after costs over long periods, which is the case usually made for index funds.
External links
Ref 1180001416