Home / Wiki / A / Active Share

Active Share

Investment and Capital MarketsUpdated 17 Nov 2026

Active share is a measure of how different a portfolio’s holdings are from those of its benchmark index. It is calculated as half the sum of the absolute differences between each security’s weight in the portfolio and its weight in the benchmark, and is expressed as a percentage. A fund that holds exactly the index has an active share of 0 per cent; a fund that owns nothing in the index has an active share of 100 per cent.

The measure was introduced by Martijn Cremers and Antti Petajisto in a paper published in the Review of Financial Studies in 2009. It is used by fund selectors, consultants and regulators to judge whether a fund marketed as active management is genuinely different from a cheaper exchange-traded fund or index fund. It is usually read alongside tracking error, which measures how much a fund’s returns, rather than its holdings, deviate from the benchmark.

01

Formula and example

The standard calculation is:

Active share=12∑i=1N∣wfund,i−windex,i∣\text{Active share} = \frac{1}{2} \sum_{i=1}^{N} \left| w_{\text{fund},i} - w_{\text{index},i} \right|
  • wfund,iw_{\text{fund},i} is the weight of security ii in the portfolio.
  • windex,iw_{\text{index},i} is the weight of the same security in the benchmark.
  • NN is the number of securities held by either the portfolio or the benchmark.

The sum is halved because every overweight position must be funded by underweights elsewhere, so without halving each difference would be counted twice.

Consider a benchmark of four stocks weighted A 40 per cent, B 30 per cent, C 20 per cent and D 10 per cent. A fund holds A 20 per cent, B 30 per cent, C 0 per cent, D 10 per cent and a non-index stock E at 40 per cent. The absolute differences are 20, 0, 20, 0 and 40 percentage points, which sum to 80. Half of 80 gives an active share of 40 per cent: four-tenths of the fund would have to be traded to turn it into the index.

02

Interpreting the measure

Cremers and Petajisto combined active share with tracking error to sort funds into styles. Funds with high active share and high tracking error take concentrated stock bets. Funds with high active share but low tracking error pick many different stocks while keeping sector and factor exposures close to the index. Funds with low active share but high tracking error make large bets on sectors or factors with relatively few stock-level differences. Funds with low active share and low tracking error were labelled closet indexers.

A closet indexer charges active fees while holding a portfolio that largely mirrors its index. After fees, such a fund is almost certain to lag the benchmark, because the small active portion cannot earn enough alpha to cover the cost of the whole fund. Active share is therefore often used to estimate the effective fee paid for the active part of a portfolio. If a fund with an active share of 25 per cent charges 1 per cent a year, the investor is in effect paying around 4 per cent a year for the quarter of the portfolio that differs from the index.

03

Uses in practice

  • Fund selection. Consultants and wealth managers screen funds by active share before looking at performance, so that low-conviction strategies are identified early.
  • Regulatory review. European supervisors examined closet indexing in the mid-2010s, and active share was one of the screening measures used to identify funds whose fees and marketing might not match their holdings.
  • Manager monitoring. Investors track a manager’s active share over time; a steady fall can signal style drift or growing assets that are harder to deploy in concentrated positions.
  • Fee negotiation. Institutions sometimes compare fees with active share to judge whether a mandate is priced fairly against passive management.
04

Limitations

Active share depends heavily on the benchmark chosen. A small-cap fund measured against a large-cap index will show a very high active share simply because it holds different companies, not because the manager is unusually skilful. The figure is also mechanically higher for a benchmark index with many constituents and for portfolios that hold few stocks.

It ignores correlation between holdings. Two stocks in the same industry may behave almost identically, so swapping one for the other raises active share without changing risk much. This is why it should be read with tracking error and factor model exposures. Active share also says nothing about whether the active positions are good ones: high active share is a precondition for outperforming an index by a wide margin, but it is equally a precondition for underperforming by a wide margin.

Later academic work questioned whether high active share predicts better returns once fund size, style and benchmark effects are controlled for. The measure remains widely used as a description of how a portfolio is built rather than as a forecast of results, and it is often reported alongside the information ratio and portfolio turnover in fund factsheets and due diligence questionnaires.

Last updated 17 Nov 2026