A variance swap is an over-the-counter derivative that lets two parties exchange a fixed level of variance for the variance actually realised by an asset over the life of the contract. It is economically a forward contract on realised variance: at maturity, the buyer receives a payment if the asset's realised variance has been higher than the strike agreed at the outset, and pays the seller if it has been lower. The underlying is most often an equity index, but single stocks, currencies and commodities are also used.
Variance swaps give pure exposure to volatility without the need to trade and continuously hedge options, which makes them popular with hedge funds, banks' derivatives desks and investors who want to bet on, or hedge against, turbulent markets. They are documented under master agreements published by the International Swaps and Derivatives Association (ISDA) and settle in cash.
Payoff and notional
Realised variance is calculated from daily closing prices over the observation period, using the sum of squared logarithmic returns, annualised and multiplied by 10,000 so that it is expressed in volatility points squared:
Here is the closing price on day , is the number of daily returns and 252 is the usual number of trading days in a year. Most contracts assume a mean return of zero, so the formula differs slightly from the textbook variance. The payoff to the buyer at maturity is:
where is the strike quoted in volatility points and is the variance notional, the amount paid per point of variance. Because traders think in volatility, trades are usually sized by vega notional, the approximate gain or loss for a one-point move in volatility near the strike, and converted with:
For example, a trade with a vega notional of 100,000 and a strike of 20 has a variance notional of 100,000 divided by 40, or 2,500. If realised volatility turns out to be 25, the buyer receives 2,500 times (625 minus 400), or 562,500. If it is 15, the buyer pays 2,500 times (400 minus 225), or 437,500. The asymmetry, a larger gain than loss for the same five-point move, reflects the convexity of variance in volatility; a volatility swap, which pays on volatility directly, would have produced 500,000 either way.
Pricing and replication
A key reason variance swaps became widely traded is that they can be replicated with a static portfolio of ordinary options across a wide range of strikes, weighted in inverse proportion to the square of the strike, combined with a delta hedge in the underlying. Research by dealers in the late 1990s set out this result, and it means the fair variance strike can be read from the prices of listed options rather than from a particular model. In practice the strike is usually set somewhat above at-the-money implied volatility, reflecting the skew in option prices and the premium investors pay for protection against market falls.
The same replication idea underlies the Cboe Volatility Index (VIX), whose methodology since 2003 calculates expected 30-day variance of the S&P 500 from a strip of index option prices. The VIX can therefore be thought of as the square root of a 30-day variance swap rate on the index.
Uses
- Volatility trading. Investors who expect realised volatility to exceed the level implied by option prices buy variance; those who expect calm sell it to collect the premium, a form of volatility arbitrage.
- Hedging. Long variance positions gain in sell-offs, when volatility tends to spike, so they are used as tail-risk hedges for equity portfolios.
- Correlation and dispersion. Selling index variance and buying variance on index members is a standard dispersion trade, a bet on correlation also expressed through a correlation swap.
Losses in 2008 and contract changes
The convexity that benefits buyers is a risk for sellers. Before the 2008 financial crisis, many dealers and funds were short variance, especially on single stocks, where demand from structured products had left banks with large exposures. When volatility surged in late 2008, realised variance on some shares rose to many times the strike, producing heavy losses and exposing the difficulty of hedging single-stock variance when markets gap and liquidity disappears.
The market changed as a result. Trading in uncapped single-stock variance largely dried up, and caps on realised variance, commonly set at a multiple of the strike, became standard, particularly for single names. Index variance swaps remained active, and related products such as listed variance futures, variance options and corridor variance swaps, which accrue variance only when the underlying trades within a range, gave investors further ways to shape their exposure. Comparing realised with historical volatility and implied levels remains the core of how these contracts are analysed.
Ref 1100001614