Convexity, in bond markets, is a measure of how the sensitivity of a bond's price to interest rates itself changes as rates move. The price of a bond falls when its yield rises, but the relationship is a curve, not a straight line. Duration describes the slope of that curve at a point, and convexity describes how much the curve bends. Portfolio managers, traders and risk managers use it to estimate price changes more accurately and to compare bonds.
The measure is a refinement of duration and is used alongside it in managing interest rate risk. For an ordinary bond without options the curve bends in the holder's favour, so that the price rises more when yields fall than it drops when yields rise by the same amount. For bonds that can be redeemed early the bend can go the other way.
Formula and example
Convexity is the second derivative of price with respect to yield, scaled by price. Its practical use is in the two-term approximation of a price change:
- is the proportional change in the bond's price.
- is the modified duration of the bond.
- is its convexity.
- is the change in yield, written as a decimal, so that one percentage point is 0.01.
Take a bond with a modified duration of 7 and a convexity of 60. If its yield rises by one percentage point, the duration term gives percent and the convexity term gives percent, for an estimated price change of -6.70 percent. If the yield falls by one percentage point, the duration term is +7.00 percent and the convexity term is again +0.30 percent, for an estimated change of +7.30 percent. The convexity term is positive in both cases, because the yield change is squared.
For small moves the correction is negligible. For a move of one basis point the convexity term in this example is 0.00003 percent, which is why measures such as basis point value rely on duration alone. The correction grows with the square of the yield change and becomes important in large moves.
What determines convexity
Convexity depends on how a bond's cash flows are spread over time. Among bonds without options:
- Maturity. Longer bonds have greater convexity, which rises roughly with the square of maturity.
- Coupon. For a given maturity, a lower coupon rate means higher convexity. A zero-coupon bond has the highest convexity of any bond of its maturity.
- Yield. Convexity is higher when yields are low.
- Dispersion of cash flows. Of two portfolios with the same duration, the one whose cash flows are more spread out has more convexity. A barbell holding short and long bonds is more convex than a bullet concentrated in the middle of the yield curve.
Negative convexity
Some bonds give the issuer or borrower the right to repay early. A callable bond will be redeemed if rates fall far enough, so its price cannot rise much above the call price. As yields decline, the price-yield curve flattens and then bends the wrong way: the bond gains less from a fall in yields than it loses from a rise. This is negative convexity.
A mortgage-backed security behaves the same way because homeowners refinance when rates drop. Prepayment shortens the security just when the investor would like it to lengthen, and slower prepayment extends it when rates rise. For these instruments analysts calculate effective convexity, which reprices the bond with a model that allows cash flows to change with rates. Structures such as the companion bond concentrate this behaviour in particular classes.
Uses
Convexity improves estimates of how a bond or portfolio will respond to a rate shock and so feeds risk limits and stress tests. In portfolio construction, two portfolios can be matched for duration and still behave differently in a large move. Institutions that match assets to liabilities, such as pension funds and insurers, therefore match convexity as well.
Positive convexity is valuable, and the market charges for it. More convex bonds usually trade at lower yields than less convex bonds of the same duration, so an investor pays for the benefit through reduced income. The benefit is realized only if yields actually move substantially, which makes a preference for convexity partly a view on interest rate volatility. Investors accept negative convexity in exchange for higher yields.
Large holders of mortgage securities hedge their changing duration by buying or selling Treasury securities or swaps. When rates fall, expected prepayments rise and the duration of their mortgage holdings shortens, so they buy longer bonds to restore it, and when rates rise they sell. This convexity hedging pushes in the same direction as the original move and has at times amplified swings in bond yields.
Limitations
The duration-and-convexity formula is still an approximation. It assumes that yields at all maturities move by the same amount, whereas actual moves usually change the slope and shape of the curve. It also depends on the model used for bond pricing, and for bonds with options the result is only as good as the assumptions about how issuers and borrowers will behave. Convexity figures are quoted on different scales by different systems, sometimes divided by 100, so numbers from two sources may not be directly comparable. Finally, the measure addresses interest rates only and says nothing about credit or liquidity risk.