Valuing environmental costs and benefits is the part of environmental economics that puts money values on things that are not bought and sold in markets, such as clean air, quiet streets, wildlife and a stable climate. Without such values, these goods tend to count as zero in cost-benefit analysis, so projects that damage the environment can look better than they are, and policies that protect it can look worse.
Economists use two broad families of methods. Stated-preference methods, such as contingent valuation, ask people directly what they would pay. Revealed-preference methods, such as hedonic pricing, infer values from choices people make in real markets. Because many environmental effects, especially climate change, stretch over decades, the results must also be converted into present values using a social discount rate. The choice of that rate is often as important as the valuation itself.
Contingent Valuation
Contingent valuation is a survey method that asks people how much they would be willing to pay for an environmental improvement, or willing to accept as compensation for a loss, in a carefully described hypothetical scenario. Answers are used to estimate the total value of goods such as a cleaner river, a protected forest or a reduced risk of oil spills. It is a stated-preference method because it relies on what people say rather than what they do, and it can capture non-use values, such as the value of knowing a species survives.
The method became prominent after the 1989 Exxon Valdez oil spill in Alaska, when it was used to estimate damages, and a 1993 panel for the US National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, which included Kenneth Arrow and Robert Solow, set guidelines for its use. Critics point to hypothetical bias, since people may overstate what they would really pay, and to answers that barely change with the scale of the good on offer. Results are usually expressed through willingness to pay.
Hedonic Pricing
Hedonic pricing is a revealed-preference method that infers the value of environmental features from the prices of goods that include them, most often houses. Two otherwise similar homes may sell for different prices because one is near a park, has cleaner air or is far from an airport. By using regression on many sales, with controls for size, age, location and other features, economists estimate how much each attribute adds to or subtracts from the price. The same approach applied to wages estimates how much workers must be paid to accept risky jobs.
A study might find, for example, that each extra unit of an air pollution measure lowers house prices by a certain percentage, giving an implicit price for cleaner air. The method relies on actual transactions but captures only values that home buyers know about and can act on, and it misses non-use values. It is distinct from hedonic adjustment, which statistical agencies use to correct price indices such as the consumer price index for quality changes.
The social discount rate is the rate used to convert future costs and benefits for society into present values, so that they can be compared with costs paid today. The present value of an effect worth in years is:
where is the discount rate. Many economists build from the Ramsey formula, , where is pure time preference, measures how fast the value of extra consumption falls as people get richer, and is growth in consumption per head.
The choice matters enormously for climate change policy. The 2006 Stern Review used a very low pure time preference, giving a rate of about 1.4%, and called for strong early action; William Nordhaus argued for higher, market-based rates and a more gradual policy. Damage worth 1,000,000 in 100 years has a present value of about 249,000 at 1.4%, but only about 4,700 at 5.5%. The UK Treasury's Green Book uses 3.5% for the first 30 years, declining thereafter.
How the methods fit together
In a typical appraisal, contingent valuation or hedonic pricing supplies the value of each year's environmental effect, the social discount rate turns the stream of effects into a single present value, and the result enters a net present value calculation alongside ordinary financial costs. The same values can help set the level of a Pigouvian tax or the cap in emissions trading, two of the environmental policy instruments used to correct a negative externality. They also help address missing markets for goods such as clean air, which no one can easily buy or sell.
Ref 1100001753
Social Discount Rate