The underwriting spread, also called the gross spread, is the difference between the price at which a new issue of securities is sold to the public and the price the underwriters pay the issuer for it. It is the main compensation of the banks that manage and distribute the offering, and it covers their advice, their marketing and selling effort, and the risk they take in committing to buy the securities. The spread is usually expressed in money per share or per bond and as a percentage of the offering price.
The spread arises in underwriting of equity and debt, including an initial public offering, a follow-on offering, corporate bonds and municipal bonds. It is shared among the members of the underwriting syndicate and selling group, and it is disclosed in the prospectus, typically on the cover page alongside the public offering price and the proceeds to the issuer.
Formula and example
The spread per unit and as a percentage are:
- POP is the public offering price per share or per bond.
- Proceeds per unit to issuer is the amount the underwriters pay the issuer for each share or bond, before the issuer's other expenses.
As a worked example, a company sells 10 million shares in an IPO at 20.00 dollars each, with a gross spread of 7 percent. The spread is dollars per share, so the issuer receives dollars per share, or 186 million dollars in total. Investors pay 200 million dollars, and the underwriters' gross compensation is million dollars. If the deal also included an over-allotment through a greenshoe option and it was exercised, the spread would be earned on those extra shares as well.
Components of the spread
In US practice, the gross spread is traditionally divided into three parts:
- Management fee. Paid to the lead and co-managing underwriters for structuring the deal, preparing documents, running the roadshow and setting the price.
- Underwriting fee. Paid to all syndicate members in proportion to their commitments, to compensate for the risk of buying the issue and for stabilisation costs; syndicate expenses are deducted from it.
- Selling concession. Paid to the firms that actually place the securities with investors, usually the largest share of the spread.
In a common split for equity deals, the selling concession accounts for around 60 percent of the spread and the management and underwriting fees for about 20 percent each, though the division is negotiated deal by deal. In municipal bond underwriting the spread is described in slightly different terms, with the largest part called the takedown, plus a management fee, expenses and sometimes a risk component.
What determines the size of the spread
Spreads vary widely with the type of security and the size and risk of the deal. Equity spreads are much higher than bond spreads, because shares are harder to value and sell and their prices are more volatile. Larger deals usually carry lower percentage spreads, since fixed costs are spread over more proceeds. Investment-grade corporate bonds and municipal bonds sold through a competitive sale typically carry spreads of well under 1 percent, while high-yield bonds and small or risky equity offerings carry more.
The structure of the commitment also matters. In a firm commitment underwriting the banks bear the risk of unsold securities, which justifies a larger fee than in an agency deal.
Regulation and debate
In the United States, FINRA Rule 5110, the corporate financing rule, requires member firms to file details of many public offerings and prohibits underwriting compensation that is unfair or unreasonable, taking account of all forms of payment, including warrants and expense reimbursements. For municipal securities, MSRB rules require underwriters to disclose their compensation and deal fairly with issuers.
Academic studies have drawn attention to the clustering of US IPO spreads. Research by Hsuan-Chi Chen and Jay Ritter published in 2000 found that most mid-sized US IPOs carried a gross spread of exactly 7 percent, a pattern they argued was hard to reconcile with vigorous price competition among underwriters. Others attribute the clustering to the value of analyst coverage, distribution networks and reputation. Spreads on larger IPOs and on deals in Europe and Asia tend to be lower, and direct listings and auction methods have been promoted partly as ways to avoid the cost. The spread is only one part of an issuer's total cost of going public, which also includes legal and accounting fees and any underpricing of the shares on the first day of trading.