The Municipal Securities Rulemaking Board (MSRB) is the self-regulatory organization that writes the rules governing firms in the US municipal securities market. Its rules bind the dealers and banks that underwrite, trade and sell municipal securities and, since 2010, the municipal advisors that counsel state and local governments on borrowing. The board is based in Washington, DC, and is overseen by the Securities and Exchange Commission.
The board's remit is unusual in two respects. It regulates the intermediaries in the market and has no authority over the issuers, the states, cities and agencies that sell each municipal bond. And it writes rules but does not examine firms or bring enforcement cases, tasks that fall to other agencies.
History
Until the 1970s, firms that dealt only in municipal securities were largely outside federal securities regulation. A series of sales-practice scandals led Congress to create the board in the Securities Acts Amendments of 1975, which also required municipal dealers to register. The board adopted its first rules in the following years.
The Dodd-Frank Act of 2010 widened its mandate. It gave the board authority over municipal advisors, added the protection of issuers and public pension plans to its mission alongside the protection of investors, and required that a majority of board members be independent of the regulated industry.
Functions
- Rulemaking. The board's general rules, numbered with the prefix G, set standards of conduct. They cover fair dealing, suitability of recommendations, fair pricing, best execution, advertising, supervision and record keeping. Each rule must be approved by the commission before it takes effect.
- Market transparency. The board operates the Electronic Municipal Market Access website, known as EMMA, the official free source of offering documents, issuers' continuing disclosures and trade prices. Dealers must report their trades to the board, which publishes them.
- Professional qualification. The board sets the examination requirements for municipal securities representatives, principals and municipal advisor representatives.
- Education and data. The board publishes market statistics and investor education material and supplies data to other regulators.
Notable rules
Rule G-17 requires dealers and advisors to deal fairly with all persons and forbids deceptive or unfair practice. It is the broad standard on which much of the rulebook rests. Rule G-30 requires prices and mark-ups to be fair and reasonable, and since 2018 dealers have had to disclose mark-ups to retail customers on certain trades. MSRB Rule G-37 restricts political contributions by firms seeking business from issuers, and Rule G-42 sets out the duties of municipal advisors, including a duty of loyalty when advising a government client.
The board also regulates dealers' sales of interests in college savings plans established by states, which are legally municipal securities.
Structure and governance
The board is a private, non-profit body governed by a board of directors. Members are drawn from the public, including investors and issuers, and from regulated firms: dealers, bank dealers and municipal advisors. Public members hold the majority. The organization is funded mainly by fees charged to regulated firms, based on their underwriting and trading activity, and receives no money from Congress.
Enforcement by other bodies
Compliance with the board's rules is checked and enforced by others. The Financial Industry Regulatory Authority examines each broker-dealer that is among its members. Bank dealers are examined by their banking supervisors: the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency, the Federal Reserve or the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation. The commission examines municipal advisors and can bring cases against any regulated party.
Criticism and limits
The division between rule writer and enforcers is often criticized as cumbersome, since the body that drafts a rule does not see how it works in examinations. A second limit is the absence of authority over issuers. Disclosure by state and local governments is slower and less uniform than that of listed companies, and the board can only improve the system through which documents are published, not their content or timing. Dealers, for their part, have objected to the cost of the board's fees and of successive transparency requirements.
Supporters credit the board with making a fragmented dealer market far more open. Before EMMA, an individual investor had little access to the price at which a bond last traded or to an issuer's financial statements.