Types of commodity hedge are the standard ways in which producers, processors, merchants and consumers of commodities use futures and related contracts to reduce exposure to price changes. Each type is defined by what the firm owns or has committed to in the physical market and by the opposite position it takes in futures. Hedging of this kind is the main commercial use of commodity exchanges, and firms that do it are classed by regulators as commercial traders.
The family runs from simple to more structured approaches. Long and short hedges are the basic directional forms. Being short the basis describes the position of a merchant that has sold forward and hedged with futures, the mirror image of being long the basis. Back-to-back hedging and tracker hedging are policies for managing a whole book of purchases or sales. None of them removes all risk: a hedger swaps flat price risk for basis risk, the risk that the gap between the local cash price and the futures price changes.
Long Hedge (Buying Hedge)
A long hedge, also called a buying hedge or consumer hedge, is the purchase of futures to protect against a rise in the price of a commodity that a firm will need to buy later. Typical users are flour millers, food processors, airlines buying jet fuel and manufacturers buying metal. If prices rise, the gain on the futures offsets the higher cost of the physical purchase. With the basis defined as cash price minus futures price, the effective purchase price is the futures price at the start plus the basis when the hedge is lifted:
Here is the futures price when the hedge is placed and the basis when it is closed. A miller buys December wheat futures at 6.00 dollars per bushel, expecting a basis of minus 0.30 and so a cost of 5.70. By November cash wheat is 6.50 and futures 6.75, a basis of minus 0.25. The futures gain of 0.75 reduces the cash cost to , equal to . The 0.05 gap from the target is basis risk.
Short Hedge
A short hedge, also called a selling hedge or producer hedge, is the sale of futures to protect against a fall in the price of a commodity that a firm holds in inventory or expects to produce. Farmers hedging a growing crop, mining companies hedging future output, oil producers and grain elevators holding stocks are typical users. If prices fall, the gain on the short futures offsets the lower value of the physical goods; if prices rise, the firm gives up the extra gain.
The same formula applies: the effective selling price equals the futures price when the hedge is placed plus the basis when it is lifted, so a short hedger benefits if the basis strengthens. A producer wanting a price floor while keeping some upside can buy a put option instead of selling futures, paying a premium for that flexibility. Where no futures exist for the exact commodity, a firm may use a related contract, a cross hedge, which adds a further layer of basis risk.
Short the Basis
Being short the basis is the position of a firm that has committed to sell a cash commodity at a fixed price that it has not yet bought, and has hedged by buying futures. It is short the physical commodity and long futures, so it profits if the basis weakens, meaning the cash price falls relative to futures before it buys the physical goods it needs. It is the opposite of being long the basis, the position of a firm that owns inventory and has sold futures against it.
A grain exporter that sells wheat to a foreign buyer at a fixed price for shipment in March, and buys March futures to cover the price risk, is short the basis. If local farmers later sell their grain cheaply relative to futures, the exporter buys the cash grain at a weaker basis and earns more than it planned. If the basis strengthens, its margin shrinks. Merchants often treat the basis, rather than the flat price, as the price they are actually trading.
Back-to-Back Hedging
Back-to-back hedging is a practice in which a commodity trader closes each physical position as soon as it opens by entering into an offsetting deal with matching quantity, timing and pricing terms. A metals merchant that buys concentrate priced on the average of a month's exchange prices might at once sell the same tonnage priced on the same average, or a trader buying a cargo at a fixed price might sell it on at a fixed price the same day.
The approach leaves the firm with almost no exposure to flat price moves, so its earnings come from the margin built into the two deals, logistics and quality optimisation rather than from market direction. The cost is that the trader cannot profit from favourable price moves, and it still carries counterparty risk, delivery risk and any mismatch in quality, dates or pricing periods between the two legs. Where one leg cannot be matched exactly, the gap is often closed with futures.
Tracker Hedging
Tracker hedging is a buying strategy in which a commodity consumer fixes the price on a growing share of its future needs as the delivery period approaches, rather than locking in all its requirements at once. A company buying energy, metal or grain for next year might fix a set percentage of its expected volume each month or quarter, often within minimum and maximum bands set by its risk policy, and leave the rest floating at market prices.
The result resembles dollar cost averaging applied to costs: the final price is an average of many fixing dates, which smooths budgets and avoids the risk of hedging everything at a peak, though it also prevents buying everything at a low. Tracker contracts offered by suppliers let customers fix tranches against an exchange or forward price when they choose. Variants set the hedge ratio by rule, increasing cover when prices fall below budget levels.
How the hedge types compare
| Type | Physical position | Futures position | Typical user | Main remaining risk |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Long hedge | Will buy later | Long | Miller, airline | Basis risk |
| Short hedge | Owns or will produce | Short | Farmer, miner | Basis risk |
| Short the basis | Sold forward, not yet bought | Long | Exporter, merchant | Basis strengthening |
| Back-to-back | Matched purchase and sale | Usually none | Physical trader | Counterparty and mismatch |
| Tracker | Future purchases | Built up over time | Industrial buyer | Unhedged share |
External links
Ref 1100001914