A cross hedge is a hedge in which the instrument used differs from the asset whose price risk is being covered. It is chosen when no futures or other derivative exists for the exact asset, or when the one that exists is too thinly traded to use. The hedger picks a contract on something whose price tends to move in step with the exposure and takes a position in that instead.
The standard example is an airline. There is no deep futures market in jet fuel, so airlines have long covered part of their fuel cost with contracts on crude oil, heating oil or diesel. Other cases include a grower of grain sorghum using corn futures, a holder of corporate bonds using Treasury futures, and a company with income in a minor currency using a contract on a closely linked major one. The approach is a normal part of hedging practice, but it protects less completely than a direct hedge.
The minimum-variance hedge ratio
Because the two prices do not move one for one, the hedger must decide how much of the hedging contract to hold for each unit of exposure. This is the hedge ratio. The ratio that leaves the smallest variation in the value of the combined position is:
- is the minimum-variance hedge ratio.
- is the correlation between changes in the price of the asset being hedged and changes in the futures price.
- is the standard deviation of changes in the price of the asset being hedged.
- is the standard deviation of changes in the futures price.
The number of contracts follows from the size of the exposure and of one contract:
where is the quantity to be hedged and is the quantity covered by one futures contract. The same ratio is the slope found by regression analysis of changes in the asset price on changes in the futures price.
Worked example
An airline expects to buy 1,000,000 gallons of jet fuel in three months and decides to hedge with heating oil futures of 42,000 gallons each. From past data, the standard deviation of monthly changes in the jet fuel price is 0.030 dollars a gallon, that of the futures price is 0.040, and the correlation between them is 0.90.
The hedge ratio is . The number of contracts is , so the airline buys 16 contracts. Hedging the full quantity one for one would have required about 24. The share of the variance removed by the hedge equals the square of the correlation, here , or 81 percent. The remaining 19 percent stays with the airline.
Basis risk in a cross hedge
Every futures hedge carries basis risk, the chance that the cash price and the futures price do not move together. In a cross hedge this risk is larger, because the basis includes the gap between two different goods as well as differences of place and timing. The prices of two refined fuels can separate when one is in short supply. The yields on corporate and government bonds diverge sharply in a credit crisis, precisely when the hedge is needed most.
Statistical relationships are measured from history and can change. A correlation of 0.90 over five years may conceal months in which the two prices moved in opposite directions. Hedgers therefore re-estimate the ratio from time to time and often hedge only part of an exposure.
Uses beyond commodities
- Share portfolios. A portfolio that does not match any index can be covered with index futures, scaling the position by the portfolio's sensitivity to the index, as in a beta hedge.
- Bonds and loans. Interest rate exposure on corporate debt is commonly covered with government bond futures or an interest rate swap, leaving the credit spread unhedged.
- Currencies. A currency risk in a currency with no liquid forward market may be covered with a proxy currency that tracks it.
Accounting and practical considerations
Under the rules on hedge accounting, a company may match gains and losses on a hedge with those on the item hedged only if it documents the relationship and shows that the hedge is effective. A cross hedge is harder to qualify than a direct one, and the part that does not offset must be recognized in profit or loss as it arises. Measures of hedge effectiveness are therefore monitored through the life of the position.
The choice of contract involves a trade-off. A closely related contract with little trading may cost more to enter and exit than a looser match with deep liquidity. Hedgers generally prefer the liquid contract with the highest correlation over the period that matches the life of the exposure.