What is a treaty?
Definition: A treaty is a written agreement between states, or between states and international organisations, that is governed by international law. It creates binding rights and duties for the parties.
A treaty in international law is a written agreement concluded between states, and in some cases international organisations, that is governed by international law, whatever it is called. The 1969 Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties, in force since 1980, defines the term in this way and sets the main rules on making, interpreting and ending treaties. Instruments of this type are known by many names, including convention, covenant, protocol, charter, accord and agreement; the name does not decide whether the document is a treaty.
Treaties are the main way in which states create obligations among themselves, including obligations that involve money. They are used for trade, tax, borders, human rights and the creation of bodies such as the International Monetary Fund (IMF), whose founding Articles of Agreement came out of the Bretton Woods System. Treaties may be bilateral, between two states, or multilateral, among many. The basic principle is that a treaty in force must be performed in good faith, and a state cannot rely on its own domestic law as a reason for failing to perform it.
Formation and entry into force
A treaty is negotiated by representatives of the states, adopted, and then signed. Signature by itself usually does not bind the state; it shows that the text is settled and creates an obligation not to defeat the treaty's purpose before the state decides whether to be bound. A state expresses its consent to be bound through ratification, acceptance, approval or accession, and the treaty enters into force as provided in its own text, for instance after a set number of states have ratified it.
States can attach reservations, which are statements that exclude or modify the effect of some provisions for that state, unless the treaty prohibits them or they are incompatible with its object and purpose. A depositary, such as the United Nations Secretary-General, keeps the instruments and informs the parties. Treaties may be ended or suspended by their terms, by agreement, or for reasons such as fundamental breach.
Treaties and financial obligations
Many treaties create payment obligations. Peace treaties have imposed War Reparations, the best known being those after the First World War. Development and aid agreements commit donors to give grants or loans, as with Official Development Assistance (ODA), and creditor and debtor governments sign bilateral agreements to give effect to debt restructuring and relief, in which the lenders are known as official creditors. Membership treaties of international organisations set subscriptions, such as the assessed contributions paid by member states.
Not every arrangement of this type is a treaty. The Paris Club, for example, records its debt treatments, described in Paris Club Debt Treatment Terms, in agreed minutes that are not themselves legally binding treaties, and the creditor governments then conclude bilateral agreements with the debtor, which are binding. Tax treaties allocate taxing rights between states to avoid double taxation. The difference between binding and non-binding instruments matters for enforcement and for how a payment duty is treated in national government spending. Presidential directives, such as an Executive Order (US), are domestic instruments and are not treaties.
Executive Agreement
An executive agreement is an international agreement made by a head of state or government without going through the formal treaty ratification process. In United States practice, the Constitution's treaty clause requires the President to obtain the advice and consent of two-thirds of the Senators present, whereas many agreements are made in other ways. Congressional-executive agreements are approved by a majority of both houses of Congress, and sole executive agreements are made on the President's own constitutional authority.
Under international law, an executive agreement binds the United States just as a treaty does. Domestically, the Case-Zablocki Act requires agreements other than treaties to be reported to Congress. Executive agreements are common in trade, defence and aid, for example arrangements for payment of military sales or assistance, and may implement an earlier treaty. Other countries use similar terms differently, and the label alone does not show the legal effect.
Memorandum of Agreement (MOA)
A memorandum of agreement (MOA) is a written agreement that sets out the roles and duties of the parties, usually in more detail and with firmer commitments than a general statement of intent. Between governments it is used for matters such as sharing costs, the use of facilities, or the conduct of a joint programme. It differs from a Memorandum of Understanding (MOU), which more often records a shared intention without creating legally enforceable duties, although the line is drawn by the wording and the intention of the parties, not by the title.
Whether an MOA is a treaty depends on whether the parties intend it to be governed by international law and to create binding obligations. Many are treated as non-binding administrative arrangements between agencies. Where payment is involved, an MOA may fix who pays what and when, but it may not create a claim that can be enforced in court.
Ratification
Ratification is the formal approval by which a state confirms that it is bound by a treaty it has signed. It is normally done by the head of state or government, or the foreign minister, after any domestic approval that is required, and is completed by depositing an instrument of ratification with the depositary. Only after that deposit is the state a party; entry into force of the treaty then follows its terms.
Domestic procedures vary. In the United States, the Senate must give its advice and consent by a two-thirds vote before the President ratifies. In many countries parliament approves or authorises ratification. In the United Kingdom, a treaty is generally laid before Parliament for a set period before ratification under the Constitutional Reform and Governance Act 2010. Ratification can be a long process, particularly where a treaty requires changes to national law.
External links
Ref 1210000778