A trade-through is the execution of an order at a price that is worse than a quotation displayed on another trading venue at the time of the trade. If one exchange shows an offer to sell a stock at 20.00 and another venue executes a purchase at 20.02, the second trade has "traded through" the better 20.00 offer: the buyer paid more than necessary, and the investor who posted the better price was bypassed. The term describes the price relationship, not intent: a trade-through can arise from slow routing, outdated quote data or a venue that simply ignores prices elsewhere.
Trade-throughs are a concern in fragmented markets, where the same security trades on many exchanges, alternative trading systems and broker-dealer platforms at once. Rules against them aim to make sure that displayed limit orders at the best price are filled first, wherever they rest. The idea is related to, but narrower than, a broker's duty of best execution to its customers.
The US Order Protection Rule
In the United States, trade-throughs in listed stocks are governed by the Order Protection Rule, Rule 611 of Regulation NMS, adopted by the Securities and Exchange Commission in 2005 and phased in during 2007. It requires each trading centre to have written policies and procedures reasonably designed to prevent trade-throughs of "protected quotations".
A protected quotation is the best displayed bid or offer of an exchange or quoting market that can be accessed immediately and automatically. Only these top-of-book automated quotes are protected; manual quotes and depth below the best price on each venue are not. The best protected prices across all venues together form the National Best Bid and Offer, and a trading centre that cannot match the best protected price must route the order to the venue displaying it or decline to execute at the inferior price. Venues meet the requirement mainly through automated routing logic that checks the consolidated quote before each execution, and the SEC and FINRA examine trading centres for patterns of trade-throughs that their procedures failed to catch.
Before Regulation NMS, an older intermarket trade-through rule applied to exchange-listed stocks, but it did not cover Nasdaq securities and allowed slower manual markets to hold up trading. The new rule applied to all national market system stocks and protected only fast, automated quotes.
Exceptions
The rule contains exceptions that allow certain trades at prices outside the best protected quote. The most important are:
- Intermarket sweep orders. A trader may send orders simultaneously to every venue displaying a better price and execute at the next price level at the same time, without waiting for each better quote to be cleared first.
- Flickering quotes. A trade is permitted if the better quote was displayed for only a very short period before the trade, which allows for quotes that change faster than orders can be routed.
- Self-help. A venue may disregard the quotes of another market that is experiencing a failure or repeatedly not responding.
- Benchmark and special trades. Trades priced by reference to a benchmark not tied to the current quote, such as a volume-weighted average price, and certain stopped orders and crossed-market situations are excepted.
Effects and criticism
Supporters argue that the rule rewards investors who post displayed limit orders, encouraging liquidity provision and helping price discovery, and that it protects retail orders from being filled at inferior prices. It is a central reason why US equity trading is held together by a dense network of routing links between venues.
Critics say the rule contributed to market fragmentation and to the rise of high-frequency trading, because firms compete to update and access protected quotes faster than others. Others note that protecting only the top of each venue's book can encourage venues to post small, short-lived quotes, and that large orders still need to sweep multiple venues. Some have argued that a rule of this kind is unnecessary given the separate duty of best execution. The SEC has reviewed the rule periodically without repealing it.
Outside US equities
Comparable rules exist in other markets. US listed options are covered by a separate options order protection and locked or crossed market plan, and Canada applies its own order protection rule to equities. In the European Union, the Markets in Financial Instruments Directive relies mainly on best execution duties rather than a trade-through prohibition.