Stock option and equity award terms are the vocabulary of employee equity plans in the United States, in which companies pay part of their staff's compensation in shares or rights linked to the share price. The main award types, the incentive stock option (ISO), the restricted stock unit (RSU) and the employee stock purchase plan (ESPP), have their own pages; this page gathers the related terms that come up around them.
Three of the sections describe further award types: the non-qualified stock option, the stock appreciation right and the performance stock unit. The employee stock option family shares a common timeline, starting at the grant date, running through a vesting period and ending with a decision about how to exercise. The last two sections cover the two basic exercise choices and their tax effects. All of these awards fall under the broader heading of equity compensation.
Non-Qualified Stock Option (NQSO)
A non-qualified stock option (NQSO or NSO) is a stock option that does not meet the requirements of section 422 of the Internal Revenue Code and so receives no special tax treatment. It gives the holder the right to buy company shares at a fixed exercise price for a set period, usually up to ten years.
When an NQSO is exercised, the spread between the market value of the shares and the exercise price is taxed as ordinary income. For an employee it is treated as wages: it appears on Form W-2 and is subject to income tax withholding and payroll taxes, and the company receives a matching tax deduction. Any later rise in value is capital gain, with the holding period starting at exercise. Unlike ISOs, NQSOs can be granted to directors, consultants and other non-employees, and have no annual value limit, which makes them the most widely used option type.
Stock Appreciation Right (SAR)
A stock appreciation right (SAR) is an award that pays the holder the increase in a company's share price above a base price, usually the market price on the grant date, over a set number of shares. Unlike an option, the holder pays nothing to exercise it: the company simply delivers the gain, either in cash or in shares of equivalent value.
For example, a SAR over 1,000 shares with a base price of $20 exercised when the shares trade at $32 is worth $12,000, paid as cash or as 375 shares at $32. The value received is taxed as ordinary income at exercise, like an NQSO. SARs are sometimes granted in tandem with options, so that exercising one cancels the other. They differ from phantom stock, which pays the full value of notional shares rather than only the appreciation. Stock-settled SARs cause less dilution than options because only the gain is issued in shares.
Performance Stock Unit (PSU)
A performance stock unit (PSU) is an equity award that converts into shares only if the company meets specified performance goals over a set period, typically three years, as well as the holder remaining employed. Related awards are called performance shares or performance stock awards (PSAs); the difference is mainly whether shares are issued at the start or only after the goals are measured.
The goals may be financial, such as earnings per share, revenue or return on capital, or market-based, such as total shareholder return relative to a peer group. Payouts are usually set as a percentage of a target number of units and can range from zero up to a cap, often 150% or 200% of target, depending on results. Once earned and settled, PSUs are taxed like RSUs: the market value of the shares delivered is ordinary income. They are widely used for senior executives to link pay to company performance.
Grant Date
The grant date is the date on which a company formally awards an option, RSU, SAR or other equity award to a recipient, usually through approval by the board or its compensation committee. It is the starting point of the award's life: vesting schedules, including any cliff vesting, are counted from it, and for an ISO it begins the two-year holding period needed for a qualifying disposition.
For options and SARs, the grant date normally fixes the exercise or base price, which is set at the fair market value of the shares that day. Setting it lower can cause adverse tax consequences under section 409A of the tax code and, for ISOs, loss of qualified status. Under US accounting rules, the award's fair value measured at the grant date is the basis for the compensation expense the company recognizes over the vesting period. Backdating of grant dates to pick a lower price was the subject of a wave of enforcement cases in the mid-2000s.
Exercise and Hold
Exercise and hold, also called a cash exercise, is the choice to pay the full exercise price, usually in cash, and keep all the shares received. The holder becomes a shareholder and takes on the risk and reward of future price changes.
The tax effect depends on the option type. For an NQSO, the spread at exercise is taxed immediately as ordinary income, so the holder must fund both the purchase price and the tax withholding without any sale proceeds. For an ISO, no regular tax is due at exercise, but the spread may create alternative minimum tax, and holding the shares at least one year after exercise and two years after grant allows the whole gain to be taxed as long-term capital gain. The main drawback is concentration risk: much of the holder's wealth becomes tied to the same company that pays the salary.
Exercise and Sell
Exercise and sell, also called a same-day sale or cashless exercise, is the choice to exercise options and immediately sell all the resulting shares. The broker handling the plan effectively advances the exercise price and settles the trade, and the holder receives the spread in cash after deducting the exercise price, commissions and fees, and tax withholding.
No money is needed up front and no market risk remains, but the whole gain is taxed as ordinary income. For an NQSO this is the same result as exercising at any other time. For an ISO, a same-day sale is a disqualifying disposition, so the spread becomes ordinary income, although no alternative minimum tax arises because the shares are not held past year end. A middle route, called sell-to-cover, sells only enough shares to pay the exercise price and taxes and keeps the remainder.
External links
Ref 1010001542