A restricted stock unit (RSU) is a form of equity compensation in which an employer promises to deliver a set number of its shares, or their cash value, once the employee meets vesting conditions. Until then the employee owns nothing but a contractual right: there are no shares, no voting rights and usually no dividends. RSUs became the most widely used form of equity pay at large US listed companies after accounting changes in the mid-2000s required stock options to be expensed.
A close relative is the restricted stock award (RSA), under which actual shares are issued at grant but can be forfeited until they vest. Both are "full-value" awards: unlike an employee stock option, they keep some value even if the share price falls, because the holder does not pay an exercise price. The terms used in grant documents are collected under stock option and equity award terms.
How RSUs work
An RSU grant states the number of units, the vesting period and the conditions for delivery. Time-based schedules often run three or four years, vesting monthly, quarterly or annually, sometimes after a one-year cliff. Performance-based units vest only if targets are met. When units vest, the company settles them, usually by issuing shares into a brokerage account, though some plans pay cash. Units that have not vested are normally forfeited when employment ends.
Private companies often use double-trigger RSUs, which vest only when both a service condition and a liquidity event, such as an initial public offering (IPO) or acquisition, have occurred. This avoids a tax bill on shares that cannot yet be sold. Many plans pay dividend equivalents, cash or extra units equal to the dividends paid on the underlying shares while the units are outstanding.
Taxation of RSUs in the United States
RSUs are not taxed at grant. At vesting, or at delivery if settlement is deferred, the fair market value of the shares is treated as wages and taxed as ordinary income, appears on the employee's Form W-2 and is subject to Social Security and Medicare taxes. The income is:
where is the taxable income, is the number of units vesting and is the share price on the vesting date. If 100 units vest when the share price is 50 dollars, dollars. Employers usually withhold federal income tax at a flat supplemental-wage rate and collect it by holding back shares (net settlement) or selling enough shares to cover the tax (sell-to-cover). At a 22% rate, the withholding is 1,100 dollars, or 22 shares, leaving 78 shares. The vest-date price becomes the cost basis of the shares received, and any later rise or fall is a capital gain or loss when they are sold.
Restricted stock awards and the 83(b) election
For an RSA, Section 83 of the Internal Revenue Code taxes the shares as ordinary income when they vest, at their value on that date. The holder can instead file a Section 83(b) election with the IRS within 30 days of the grant, choosing to be taxed immediately on the value at grant, less any amount paid. All later growth is then capital gain, and the capital gains holding period starts at grant. The election suits situations where the grant value is low, such as founders' shares in an early-stage company, but it carries a risk: if the shares are later forfeited, the tax already paid is not refunded. The 83(b) election is not available for RSUs, because no property is transferred until settlement.
Comparison with stock options
| Feature | RSU | Restricted stock award | Stock option |
|---|---|---|---|
| What is granted | Promise of shares | Shares, subject to forfeiture | Right to buy shares at a fixed price |
| Cost to holder | None | None or a small purchase price | Exercise price |
| Value if price falls | Reduced but positive | Reduced but positive | Can fall to zero |
| Usual US tax point | Vesting | Vesting, or grant with 83(b) | Exercise (NQSO) or sale (ISO) |
| Voting and dividends before vesting | No; dividend equivalents possible | Usually yes | No |
Because an RSU delivers value in almost any market, companies typically grant fewer RSUs than options for the same expected cost. For accounting, the company records an expense equal to the grant-date fair value of the units, spread over the vesting period, whether or not the share price later rises. Both add to the share count when settled and contribute to dilution.
Ref 1180001944