Equity compensation is pay that employees, executives, directors or advisers receive in the form of company stock or rights linked to its value, instead of or alongside cash salary and bonus. Companies use it to recruit and retain staff, to tie rewards to the share price and, in young firms, to conserve cash. It is a standard part of pay at listed technology companies and at venture-backed startups, and a large component of executive compensation across industries.
Most awards share a common life cycle: a grant, a vesting period during which the recipient must stay with the company or meet targets, and a point at which shares are delivered or an option can be exercised. The tax and accounting treatment differs sharply between types. In the United States the main tax rules come from the Internal Revenue Code and are administered by the IRS, while public companies' share plans are also subject to securities law and stock exchange listing rules.
Main forms of equity compensation
- Stock options. An employee stock option gives the right to buy shares at a fixed exercise price, normally the market price on the grant date. US options are either incentive stock options (ISOs), which meet statutory conditions, or non-qualified stock options (NQSOs).
- Restricted stock and RSUs. Restricted stock awards deliver actual shares at grant that can be forfeited until they vest; restricted stock units (RSUs) are promises to deliver shares, or their cash value, once vesting conditions are met.
- Performance shares. These vest only if targets such as earnings growth or total shareholder return are met, with the number of shares often scaled to results.
- Stock appreciation rights (SARs). A SAR pays the rise in the share price over a set base price, in cash or shares, without the holder paying an exercise price.
- Employee stock purchase plans. An employee stock purchase plan (ESPP) lets staff buy shares through payroll, often at a discount.
Some private companies also use phantom stock, a cash bonus that tracks the value of a notional number of shares without issuing any.
Grant, vesting and exercise
A grant agreement sets the number of shares or units, the vesting schedule and what happens on leaving the company, a change of control or death. Time-based schedules are commonly four years, either in equal monthly or annual installments or with cliff vesting, where nothing vests until a first anniversary. Performance conditions may replace or add to time conditions. Unvested awards are usually forfeited when employment ends, although retirement, disability and acquisition provisions can accelerate vesting. Options must be exercised within a stated term, often ten years from grant, and within a shorter window after employment ends. The terms used in these agreements are gathered under stock option and equity award terms.
Taxation in the United States
The timing of tax depends on the award type:
- NQSOs. The spread between the market price and the exercise price is taxed as ordinary income at exercise and is subject to payroll taxes.
- ISOs. No regular income tax arises at exercise, but the spread counts for the alternative minimum tax (AMT). If the shares are held more than two years from grant and one year from exercise, the whole gain on sale is taxed as long-term capital gain.
- Restricted stock and RSUs. Value is generally taxed as ordinary income when the award vests, or for restricted stock at grant if the holder files a Section 83(b) election.
- ESPPs. Qualified plans defer tax until the shares are sold, with the split between ordinary income and capital gain set by holding periods.
After shares are received, later price changes produce capital gains or losses, measured from a cost basis that includes any amount already taxed as income.
Accounting and dilution
Under US GAAP and IFRS, companies record share-based payments as an expense over the vesting period, based on the fair value of the award at grant. For options this fair value is usually estimated with an option pricing model such as the Black-Scholes model. Shares issued to settle awards add to the share count and cause dilution of existing holders, which is why many companies run a share buyback program alongside their plans and why shareholders vote on the size of the pool of shares reserved for awards.
Concentration and liquidity risks
Equity compensation ties a person's wealth to the fortunes of the employer, creating concentration risk: a fall in the share price can coincide with lower bonuses or job losses. In private companies there may be no market for the shares until an initial public offering or acquisition, and options may expire before such an event. Insiders at listed companies face trading windows, blackout periods and resale limits such as Rule 144, so shares cannot always be sold when they vest. These features make equity awards worth less to many recipients than an equal amount of cash, a gap often discussed in research on pay design.
Ref 1180001934