Soft commodities, often called softs, are commodities that are grown instead of mined or extracted. In the usual market sense the group is made up of tropical and subtropical crops: coffee, cocoa, sugar, cotton and orange juice. They are bought and sold physically by growers, merchants and processors, and through futures and options by hedgers and investors.
The term has no fixed boundary. Some sources apply it to every agricultural commodity, including cereals, oilseeds and livestock, while exchanges and index providers normally keep softs apart from grains. Timber and rubber are sometimes added. The benchmark futures contracts are listed by Intercontinental Exchange in New York and London.
The main soft commodities
- Coffee. Arabica is priced off the New York contract and robusta off the London contract. Brazil is the largest producer, and Vietnam is the main source of robusta.
- Cocoa. West Africa, led by Côte d'Ivoire and Ghana, grows well over half of the world crop. Contracts trade in both New York and London.
- Sugar. Raw sugar is priced in New York and refined white sugar in London. Brazil and India are the largest producers. Sugar cane is also made into ethanol, which ties sugar to energy prices.
- Cotton. India, China, the United States and Brazil are the major growers, and the New York contract is the world reference price.
- Orange juice. The contract is for frozen concentrate. Supply is dominated by Brazil, with Florida a much smaller producer than it once was.
How softs are traded
Most of the physical crop moves under contracts between producers, trading houses and manufacturers such as roasters, chocolate makers and textile mills. Prices in those contracts are commonly set as a premium or discount to a futures price, so the exchange contracts serve as the reference for the whole trade.
Each futures contract specifies a quantity, a contract grade and one or more delivery points, usually licensed warehouses at named ports. Commercial firms use the contracts for hedging: a grower sells futures to fix a price for a harvest, and a manufacturer buys them to fix an input cost. Funds and individual traders supply the other side. In the United States the market is overseen by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission, whose weekly Commitments of Traders report shows the positions of each group.
What moves prices
Supply is the dominant influence, and it is uncertain.
- Weather. Frost or drought in Brazil can cut the coffee, sugar and orange crops. The El Niño-Southern Oscillation shifts rainfall across the tropics and affects several softs at once.
- Disease and pests. Leaf rust in coffee, swollen shoot virus in cocoa and greening disease in citrus have each reduced output for years at a time.
- Slow supply response. Coffee and cocoa trees take several years to bear a crop, so high prices do not bring new supply quickly, and gluts are slow to clear.
- Policy and currency. Export limits, price-setting by producer governments and biofuel rules alter supply. Softs are priced in dollars, so a weaker Brazilian real encourages Brazilian growers to sell.
Demand for these goods changes little from year to year, which means that a modest shortfall can produce a large rise in price. Cocoa futures, for example, reached record highs in 2024 after poor harvests in West Africa.
Softs as an investment
Investors gain exposure through futures, through funds and notes that hold futures, and through a broad commodity index, in which softs carry a small weight beside energy and metals. The case made for holding them is diversification, since crop failures are unrelated to the business cycle. Returns to a futures position differ from the change in the spot price, because positions must be rolled from one expiry to the next, at a cost when the market is in contango and a gain when it is in backwardation.
Risks and criticism
Softs are among the more volatile commodities, and some markets, orange juice above all, are thinly traded. Production is concentrated in a few countries, which magnifies local shocks. Climate change is expected to shift the areas suited to coffee and cocoa. The sector also faces scrutiny over deforestation, child labour and the low incomes of smallholders, and buyers are under growing pressure to trace their supply chain. The effect of financial speculation on food prices remains a subject of dispute among researchers.