Soft dollars are the part of brokerage commissions that an investment manager uses to obtain research and related services, instead of paying for them in cash from its own resources. The manager sends client trades to a broker, pays a commission higher than the bare cost of execution, and receives research or other services in return. Payments made directly from the manager's own funds are called hard dollars.
The practice is long established in asset management and is lawful in the United States within a statutory safe harbor. It is also controversial, because the commissions come out of client assets while the manager chooses, and benefits from, the services they buy. European rules restricted it sharply from 2018.
How soft dollar arrangements work
In the simplest form, a full-service broker-dealer charges one bundled commission that covers both execution and its own analysts' research. The manager is not billed separately for the research, and its value is not itemized.
In a third-party arrangement, the broker agrees to pay outside vendors on the manager's behalf, in proportion to the commissions the manager generates. Under a commission sharing arrangement, the executing broker sets aside the research portion of each commission in a pool, and the manager directs payments from the pool to the research providers it chooses. This lets a manager trade with the broker that executes best while buying research elsewhere. As an illustration, if a manager pays three cents a share and execution alone would cost one cent, two cents accrue as research credits.
Legal basis in the United States
Until 1 May 1975, US stock exchange commissions were fixed, and brokers competed by supplying research. When negotiated commissions were introduced, managers feared that paying more than the lowest available rate would breach their duty as a fiduciary. Congress responded by adding Section 28(e) to the Securities Exchange Act of 1934. It protects a manager with investment discretion who pays a higher commission, provided the manager determines in good faith that the amount is reasonable in relation to the value of the brokerage and research services received.
The Securities and Exchange Commission has interpreted the provision several times, most fully in 2006. Eligible research must reflect the expression of reasoning or knowledge, such as analysis, reports and certain market data. Overhead such as rent, travel, furniture and computer hardware does not qualify, and the cost of mixed-use items must be divided. An investment adviser must describe its soft dollar practices in its disclosure brochure. Arrangements outside the safe harbor are not automatically unlawful but require clear disclosure and are judged under general fiduciary principles. Managers of pension funds face additional constraints under employee benefit law.
Rules outside the United States
The United Kingdom limited the use of commissions to execution and research in 2006. The European Union went further with MiFID II, which from January 2018 required managers to pay for research either from their own resources or from a dedicated account funded by a specific charge agreed with clients. This separation is known as unbundling. Most large European managers chose to absorb the cost.
Research budgets fell after the change, and several studies reported thinner analyst coverage of smaller companies. Partly for that reason, both the UK Financial Conduct Authority and the European Union later eased the rules to permit joint payments for execution and research again, subject to conditions. The difference between the regimes created difficulties for US brokers, which under US law cannot readily accept cash for research without being treated as advisers.
Criticism and defence
The central objection is a conflict of interest. Research paid for with commissions is a cost borne by clients that does not appear in a fund's stated management fee, and the benefit goes to the manager, who would otherwise have to buy it. Critics argue that this weakens the incentive to seek best execution, encourages unnecessary trading and a higher portfolio turnover ratio, and makes costs hard to compare. The concern is similar to that raised by payment for order flow in retail broking.
Defenders reply that research improves investment decisions and so serves clients, that soft dollars sustain independent research firms, and that they allow small managers to obtain analysis they could not afford in cash. Regulators in the US have so far preferred disclosure and limits on eligible services to outright prohibition. Investors in a mutual fund can find the fund's brokerage practices in its registration documents.