A commodity index is a calculated figure that tracks the combined price movement of a specified set of commodities, such as crude oil, natural gas, copper, gold, wheat and cattle. Most investable versions are built from the prices of futures contracts, not from the prices of the physical goods, because futures can be held without storing anything. The index gives a single number for the direction of commodity markets and a benchmark index against which investments are measured.
Indices of this kind are published by index providers and banks. They are the basis for funds, swaps and structured products that give investors exposure to commodities as an asset class. An index of spot prices, by contrast, is mainly an economic indicator and cannot be replicated by an investor in practice.
Main indices
A few families of index dominate. The S&P GSCI, launched by Goldman Sachs in 1991, weights each commodity by its share of world production, which gives energy a very large weight. The Bloomberg Commodity Index, which dates from 1998 under earlier names, combines production and trading volume and caps the weight of any one sector and commodity to keep the basket diversified. The CRB index, first calculated in the 1950s, is the oldest and has been revised many times. The Dow Jones Commodity Index gives equal weight to its broad sectors. Sub-indices cover single sectors such as energy, industrial metals, precious metals, agriculture and livestock.
How a futures-based index is built
Each index has a published rulebook that specifies which commodities are included, their target weights, which contract months are held and when positions are rolled. Because a futures contract expires, the index cannot hold it indefinitely. During a set window each month it sells the expiring contract and buys a later one, a process called rolling.
The roll has a cost or a benefit that depends on the shape of the futures curve. When later contracts are more expensive than nearer ones, a state called contango, the index sells low and buys high at each roll and loses value even if the spot price is unchanged. When later contracts are cheaper, a state called backwardation, the roll adds to the return. Over long periods this roll return has been as important as spot price changes in determining results.
Types of return
Providers publish three versions of the same index. The spot index reflects only the price of the contracts currently held. The excess return index adds the effect of rolling. The total return index further adds interest on the cash that a fully collateralized investor would hold, usually at the rate on Treasury bills. The relationship is approximately:
- is the change in the price of the nearby futures contracts.
- is the gain or loss from replacing expiring contracts with later ones.
- is the interest earned on the cash backing the position.
Suppose that in one year nearby prices rise by 4 percent, the roll costs 3 percent because the markets were in contango, and Treasury bills yield 5 percent. The excess return is percent and the total return is about percent. An investor who looked only at the 4 percent rise in spot prices would have misjudged the result.
Uses
Institutional investors began allocating to commodity indices in volume in the early 2000s, drawn by research showing that commodity futures had historically delivered equity-like returns with low correlation to shares and bonds and some protection against inflation. The case rests on diversification: an asset that behaves differently from the rest of a portfolio can lower its overall risk.
Exposure is obtained through a commodity index fund, through exchange-traded products or through a commodity index swap with a bank. The dealers and funds that buy futures to supply this exposure are identified in US regulatory data as a commodity index trader. Index levels are also quoted by economists and the press as a summary of raw material costs.
Criticism and limitations
- Roll losses. After index investing became popular, several major markets spent long periods in contango, and index returns fell well short of the rise in spot prices.
- Concentration. A production-weighted index is dominated by energy, so it behaves much like an oil investment. Capped indices avoid this but the caps are arbitrary.
- Predictable trading. Roll dates are published in advance, which lets other traders position ahead of the index. Newer indices spread the roll over more days or choose contracts further along the curve.
- Changing correlations. The low correlation with shares weakened during the 2008 crisis, when commodities and equities fell together.
A wider debate concerns whether the flow of index money raised and destabilized the prices of food and energy during 2007 and 2008. Studies have reached differing conclusions, and the question influenced later rules on position limits.