Social contributions and benefits in government finance statistics are the concepts that national accounts and government finance statistics (GFS) use to record how a society protects people against risks such as old age, sickness, disability and unemployment. On the revenue side they cover contributions paid by employees, employers and the self-employed; on the spending side they cover cash benefits and goods and services provided to households. The definitions come from the System of National Accounts 2008 and the IMF's Government Finance Statistics Manual 2014, and they shape figures such as tax-to-GDP ratios and government spending by function.
The central distinction is between social insurance, where benefits depend on contributions made in the past, and social assistance, which is paid on the basis of need without prior contributions. Transfers in kind cut across both. The broader political and economic setting is covered under welfare state and welfare, and the government units that run social insurance are covered under social security funds.
Social protection is the set of policies and programs that protect people against poverty and against social risks that reduce income or raise needs, such as old age, sickness, disability, the loss of a breadwinner, unemployment, raising children and housing costs. It has three broad parts: social insurance, financed by contributions; social assistance, financed by general taxes and targeted at need; and labor market programs such as training and job-search help, discussed under active labor market policy. In government finance statistics, social protection is also one of the ten divisions of the Classification of the Functions of Government (COFOG), usually the largest item of government spending in advanced economies. International bodies such as the International Labour Organization (ILO) and the World Bank use the term to compare coverage across countries, track how many people have no protection, and promote social protection floors, a basic set of guarantees for all residents.
Social Contributions
Social contributions are payments that employees, employers and self-employed or non-employed people make to social insurance schemes to secure entitlement to future social benefits, such as pensions, sickness pay and unemployment benefits. Contributions to government-run schemes are often called social security contributions; examples include National Insurance contributions in the United Kingdom and the Social Security and Medicare payroll taxes collected under the Federal Insurance Contributions Act in the United States. In GFSM 2014, social contributions form a separate revenue category from taxes, because paying them creates a link to future benefits. Contributions to schemes for a government's own employees are recorded as other social contributions. In practice the line can blur: some payroll taxes are levied on the same base but give no entitlement and are classified as taxes. Cross-country comparisons of tax burdens usually add social contributions to taxes, since countries fund similar benefits in different ways.
Employers' Social Contributions
Employers' social contributions are the payments employers make, or are deemed to make, to social insurance schemes for the benefit of their employees. They are part of compensation of employees in the national accounts, alongside wages and salaries, because they are a cost of employing labor. Actual contributions are amounts paid to a scheme run by government, an insurer or a pension fund, such as employer National Insurance in the United Kingdom or the employer half of US Social Security and Medicare contributions. Imputed contributions arise when an employer provides social benefits directly, without a separate fund, for example by paying sick pay or unfunded pensions from its own resources; statisticians impute a contribution equal to the value of entitlements being earned. For defined benefit pension plans, the SNA records the increase in entitlements earned by current service, which can differ from the cash actually paid in a given year.
Social Insurance Scheme
A social insurance scheme is an arrangement in which participants, or others on their behalf, make social contributions that entitle them to benefits when a defined social risk occurs, such as retirement, illness, injury at work or unemployment. In the SNA there are two main types. Social security schemes cover all or large parts of the population, are imposed and controlled by government, and are run by social security funds within general government; the US Social Security program is a standard example. Other employment-related schemes are organised by employers, often through a pension fund or insurer, for their own staff. Benefits from social insurance generally do not depend on means. The scheme can be funded, building up assets, or unfunded, paying current benefits out of current contributions, as many state pension systems do. In GFS, social insurance benefits paid by government are recorded under social benefits expense.
Social Assistance Benefit
A social assistance benefit is a payment or service that government or a non-profit institution provides to households to meet social needs, without any requirement for previous contributions to a social insurance scheme. Eligibility usually depends on an assessment of need, often a means test of income and assets, though some benefits are paid to whole groups, such as universal child allowances. Examples are minimum-income support, housing allowances, food assistance and non-contributory pensions for poor elderly people. Social assistance contrasts with social insurance benefits such as contributory unemployment benefits, which are paid because contributions were made. In GFSM 2014, social assistance benefits are a separate subcategory of social benefits expense, which allows analysts to measure how much of a government's social spending is targeted at need. The same benefit can be paid in cash or provided in kind, for example as subsidised housing.
Social Transfers in Kind
Social transfers in kind are goods and services that government units and non-profit institutions serving households provide to individual households free or at prices that are not economically significant. The main examples are education, health care, social housing and other services such as child care. They include both services that government produces itself, such as public school teaching, and goods and services it buys from market producers and passes on, such as reimbursed medicines. In the SNA the value of these transfers is moved from the consumption of government to the consumption of households, producing actual individual consumption. Adding them to disposable income gives adjusted disposable income, which allows fairer comparisons between countries where health or education is provided by government and countries where households pay for it themselves. Collective services such as defence are not included, because they cannot be assigned to individual households.
Transfer in Kind
A transfer in kind, in the economic sense, is a transfer of goods, services or assets other than cash from one unit to another with nothing of equal value given in return. Examples include food aid shipped by one government to another, medical equipment donated by a charity, a free school place, or an employer's gift of goods. Transfers in kind contrast with cash transfers, which give recipients money to spend as they choose; supporters of in-kind support argue it guarantees that needs are met, while critics argue that cash is cheaper to deliver and respects choice. In the national accounts, most transfers in kind are recorded as if the donor had made a cash transfer that the recipient then spent on the goods or services. The most important category for households is social transfers in kind, described above. Between countries, transfers in kind are part of official development assistance when given by governments for development, and are recorded in the balance of payments as secondary income or capital transfers.
How the members fit together
| Member | Side of the accounts | Linked to contributions? |
|---|---|---|
| Social contributions | Revenue | Yes, create entitlement |
| Employers' social contributions | Revenue and compensation of employees | Yes |
| Social insurance benefits | Expense | Yes |
| Social assistance benefits | Expense | No, based on need |
| Social transfers in kind | Expense and household consumption | Usually no |
External links
Ref 1010001529
Social Protection