A welfare state is a system in which the government takes primary responsibility for protecting citizens against the main risks to their economic security, including old age, sickness, disability, unemployment and poverty. It does so through cash benefits such as pensions and unemployment benefit, through services such as healthcare and education, and through support for families and people on low incomes. Spending is financed mainly by taxes and social contributions.
All high-income countries operate some form of welfare state, but they differ widely in scale and design. Social spending in many western European countries is far higher as a share of national output than in the United States, which relies more on employer-provided benefits and targeted programmes. The welfare state is closely linked to income redistribution, progressive taxation and the wider system of transfer payments, and debates about it concern cost, incentives and fairness.
Origins and history
Modern social protection is usually traced to Germany in the 1880s, when Chancellor Otto von Bismarck introduced compulsory health insurance (1883), accident insurance (1884) and old-age and disability insurance (1889), financed by contributions from workers and employers. The United Kingdom's Beveridge Report of 1942 proposed a comprehensive system to attack what William Beveridge called the five giants of want, disease, ignorance, squalor and idleness. It led to national insurance reforms and the creation of the National Health Service in 1948.
In the United States, the New Deal produced the Social Security Act of 1935, which created old-age insurance, unemployment insurance and aid to poor families. Welfare states expanded rapidly during the golden age of capitalism after the Second World War, and came under pressure from slower growth, ageing populations and rising costs from the 1970s onwards.
Models of the welfare state
Two historic models are often contrasted. The Bismarck model links benefits to employment and contributions, so that people who paid more into the system receive more. The Beveridge model aims at universal coverage funded largely from general taxation, often with flat-rate benefits. Most countries mix elements of both.
The sociologist Gøsta Esping-Andersen, in The Three Worlds of Welfare Capitalism (1990), grouped rich countries into three regimes:
- Liberal. Modest universal benefits, heavy use of means testing and a large role for markets, as in the United States, the United Kingdom and Australia.
- Conservative or corporatist. Social insurance tied to occupation and family status, as in Germany, France and Italy.
- Social democratic. Generous universal benefits and services funded by high taxes, as in Sweden, Denmark and Norway.
Later researchers added further groups, such as a southern European model and East Asian systems that emphasise family support and employment.
Social insurance is the part of the welfare state that protects people against common risks through compulsory schemes funded by contributions or earmarked taxes. Workers and employers pay in while people are working, and benefits are paid when a defined event occurs: retirement, unemployment, sickness, disability, work injury or the death of a breadwinner. Entitlement depends on the contribution record rather than on current income or wealth.
The model descends from Bismarck's German schemes. In the United States, Social Security provides retirement, disability and survivor benefits funded by Social Security taxes on wages, and Medicare covers health care for older people. Most public pension schemes are funded on a current basis, in which today's contributions fund today's pensions. Social insurance differs from private insurance because membership is compulsory, which prevents adverse selection, and because benefits often include an element of redistribution towards lower earners. Ageing populations put pressure on such schemes because fewer workers support each retiree.
Social Safety Net
A social safety net is the set of government programmes that support people who are in or near poverty, catching those whom the labour market and social insurance do not protect. It typically includes cash assistance, food aid, housing support, health cover for people on low incomes and tax credits for low-paid workers.
In the United States, major parts of the safety net include Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF), which replaced an earlier cash-aid programme in 1996 and added work requirements; the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP); Medicaid, which provides health cover described further in health insurance in the United States; Supplemental Security Income; and the Earned Income Tax Credit (EITC). Designers face trade-offs between adequacy, cost and work incentives. Many safety-net programmes are combined with welfare-to-work programs that require or encourage job search.
Means-Tested Program
A means-tested program is a government benefit for which eligibility, the amount paid, or both depend on the claimant's income, assets or both. Examples in the United States include Medicaid, SNAP and Supplemental Security Income. These contrast with universal or contributory programmes, such as Social Security retirement benefits, which are paid regardless of current means.
Means testing concentrates spending on people with the greatest need, so a given budget does more to reduce poverty. It has costs. Applicants must prove their circumstances, which deters some eligible people from claiming, and benefits withdrawn as income rises act like an extra marginal tax rate. When a small pay rise causes a large benefit to stop entirely, the result is a benefit cliff. For example, if a family earning 30,000 loses a benefit worth 2,000 when earnings reach 30,001, the extra dollar of pay leaves it about 1,999 worse off. Gradual phase-outs reduce such cliffs but extend the range of incomes facing high effective tax rates.
In-Kind Transfer
An in-kind transfer is a benefit given as goods or services, or as a voucher restricted to particular goods, rather than as cash. Examples include public housing, free school meals, food aid, subsidised childcare and free or subsidised healthcare and education. SNAP is often treated as near-cash because its electronic benefit cards can be spent only on eligible food.
Economists have long debated cash against in-kind support. Standard consumer theory suggests that a person given cash can be at least as well off as with an in-kind benefit of equal cost, because cash allows any choice. In-kind transfers are defended on paternalistic grounds, as a way to ensure that children are fed or housed, and because they are less attractive to people who do not need them, which helps target support. They also affect how poverty is measured: the official US poverty measure counts only cash income before tax, while the Supplemental Poverty Measure adds in-kind benefits and tax credits. Proposals for a universal basic income represent the opposite pole, replacing many targeted services with unconditional cash.
Funding and debates
Welfare states are financed by income taxes, payroll contributions and consumption taxes, and social spending is usually the largest item in government budgets in rich countries. Supporters argue that it reduces poverty and economic inequality, smooths consumption over the life cycle, stabilises demand in recessions and pools risks that private markets insure poorly. Critics argue that high taxes and generous benefits weaken incentives to work and save, that programmes can create dependency, and that ageing populations make current promises unaffordable. Reform debates focus on pension ages, the balance between universal and targeted support, and ideas such as predistribution, which aims to reduce inequality before taxes and transfers.
External links
Ref 1120000293
Social Insurance