Settlement efficiency is the proportion of securities transactions that settle on their intended settlement date (ISD), measured either by the number of instructions or by their value. A transaction that does not settle on that date is a settlement failure, or fail, even if it settles a day or two later. High efficiency means that buyers receive securities and sellers receive cash when expected, with fewer knock-on effects along chains of linked trades.
The measure is tracked by central securities depositories, custodians, broker-dealers and regulators. In Europe it gained prominence through the settlement discipline rules of the Central Securities Depositories Regulation (CSDR), and in the US and other markets through the move to shorter settlement cycles, which leave less time to correct problems before the settlement date.
How settlement efficiency is measured
The basic calculation compares the instructions that settled on time with all instructions due on that date:
The result is a percentage. If 10,000 instructions are due on a given day and 9,400 settle on that day, efficiency by number is per cent. If those instructions are worth 50 billion euros in total and 48 billion settle on time, efficiency by value is per cent. The two figures often differ, because large institutional trades tend to be better prepared than many small retail ones, or the reverse during market stress.
Depositories usually report both figures, and sometimes split them by asset class, by participant and by type of transaction, since a trade-related settlement instruction behaves differently from an internal account transfer. Rates for liquid government bonds are typically high, while rates for equities, exchange-traded funds and less liquid bonds are lower.
What causes settlement fails
Fails have a small number of recurring causes:
- Lack of securities. The seller does not hold the securities, often because it is waiting for an incoming delivery from another trade, a recall of loaned securities or a short sale that has not been covered.
- Lack of cash. The buyer or its payment bank has not provided enough cash or credit in time.
- Instruction problems. Instructions are late, unmatched or contain wrong details, such as an incorrect account or settlement date, so that settlement instruction matching does not take place.
- Operational and market factors. System outages, time-zone gaps, foreign exchange that must be bought before settlement and settlement chains in which one fail causes several others.
Weak straight-through processing and manual steps in the post-trade chain increase every one of these risks.
Regulation and settlement discipline
CSDR, adopted in 2014, requires EU depositories and their participants to take measures to prevent and address fails. Its settlement discipline regime, in force since 1 February 2022, imposes daily cash penalties on the participant that causes a fail, calculated for each day the instruction remains unsettled and paid to the receiving side. Depositories must also monitor and report fails to their authorities, and the European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA) publishes analysis of the data.
CSDR also provided for mandatory buy-ins, under which a failing seller's securities would be bought in the market at its cost after a set extension period. This element proved contentious and was not brought into force with the penalties. A later review of the regulation turned mandatory buy-ins into a measure that may be applied only if other tools fail to raise efficiency. Separate contractual buy-in procedures still exist in trading venue and clearing rules. In the US Treasury market, a fails charge introduced after the 2008 crisis plays a similar role in discouraging persistent fails.
Tools that improve efficiency
Settlement systems offer several features designed to raise efficiency. Partial settlement lets part of a trade settle when the full quantity is not available. A hold and release mechanism lets participants control which instructions settle first. Auto-collateralisation generates intraday credit from securities being received, and recycling keeps unsettled instructions in the queue for later attempts. Platforms such as TARGET2-Securities (T2S) combine these with optimisation routines that look for sets of instructions that can settle together.
Firms also improve results through early matching of instructions, accurate standing settlement data, automated allocation and confirmation, and active management of inventory and securities lending recalls.
Settlement cycles and T+1
The length of the settlement cycle affects efficiency directly. The US, Canada and Mexico moved most securities trades to T+1 settlement in May 2024, compressing allocation, confirmation and funding into a single day. The EU, the UK and Switzerland have planned a move to T+1 for 11 October 2027. Shorter cycles reduce counterparty and market exposure between trade and settlement, but they also leave less time to fix errors, so industry groups and regulators have treated higher automation and same-day affirmation as preconditions for the change, and closely watch efficiency rates after each transition.
Ref 1130000829