Securities lending collateral is the cash or securities that a borrower delivers to a lender to secure a loan of securities. In securities lending, the lender, such as a pension fund, insurer or investment fund, transfers shares or bonds to a borrower, usually a broker-dealer covering short sales or settlement needs. To protect the lender if the borrower fails to return the securities, the borrower provides collateral worth more than the loan, and the amount is adjusted as market values change.
Collateral is one of the main things lenders and their agents negotiate, alongside the fee or rebate. Its type determines how the lender is paid, what risks it takes and what operational work is needed. Many lenders use an agent lender, often their custodian, which manages collateral and may offer an indemnity against borrower default. Securities loans are close relatives of a repurchase agreement (repo), and collateral practices in the two markets overlap.
Cash and non-cash collateral
Collateral falls into two broad types:
- Cash collateral. The borrower delivers cash, and the lender pays the borrower interest on it at an agreed rebate rate. The lender earns by reinvesting the cash at a higher rate than the rebate. Cash has historically dominated in the United States.
- Non-cash collateral. The borrower delivers government bonds, other bonds or equities, and pays the lender an explicit fee rate for the loan. Non-cash collateral is more common in Europe and is often managed by a tri-party agent through tri-party collateral management.
Which assets count is set out in the lending agreement's schedule of eligible collateral, with concentration limits and minimum credit quality. The borrower can usually replace one asset with another through collateral substitution.
Margins and marking to market
Collateral is held at a margin above the value of the loaned securities. A widely used market convention is 102% of the loan value where loan and collateral are in the same currency and 105% where they differ, with higher levels for riskier collateral. For non-cash collateral the margin works like a collateral haircut.
The collateral required is:
where is the current market value of the loaned securities and is the margin ratio, such as 1.02. Loans and collateral are revalued every business day. If the loaned securities rise in value or the collateral falls, the lender issues a margin call for more collateral; if the reverse happens, excess collateral is returned.
Cash reinvestment and the rebate
With cash collateral, the lender's return is the spread between the reinvestment yield and the rebate paid to the borrower. For a period of days on the money-market basis of 360 days:
- is the cash collateral.
- is the reinvestment yield.
- is the rebate rate paid to the borrower.
- is the number of days.
For example, a lender holds cash collateral of 10,200,000 against a loan of shares worth 10,000,000 at 102%. It reinvests at 4.40% and pays a rebate of 4.10%, a spread of 0.30%. Over 30 days its income is . Hard-to-borrow securities command a low or even negative rebate, which raises the lender's return. For non-cash loans the calculation is simpler: the borrower pays the agreed fee rate on the value of the loaned securities, and the collateral itself earns nothing extra for the lender.
Risks and regulation
The main risk with non-cash collateral is that, if the borrower defaults, the collateral cannot be sold for enough to buy back the loaned securities, because both have moved in price. With cash collateral the main risk lies in reinvestment: if the lender buys assets that lose value or become illiquid, it may be unable to repay the cash when the loan ends, with or without a loan recall. Several large US cash reinvestment pools suffered such losses in 2008, and lenders have since favoured conservative vehicles such as money market funds or short repo.
Standard documentation, such as the Global Master Securities Lending Agreement published by the International Securities Lending Association, sets out collateral delivery, marking to market and default rights, under title transfer or, in a later version, a security interest. In the EU, securities lending trades and their collateral must be reported under the Securities Financing Transactions Regulation, and UCITS funds follow guidelines on the diversification and reinvestment of collateral.