A second-party opinion (SPO) is an independent assessment of a green, social, sustainability or sustainability-linked bond or loan framework, which states whether the framework aligns with recognised market principles and comments on its environmental or social credibility. It is commissioned and paid for by the issuer, usually before the first issue, and published so that investors can take it into account.
SPOs are the most common form of external review in the labelled bond market. They are recommended, though not required, by the ICMA Green Bond Principles, Social Bond Principles, Sustainability Bond Guidelines and Sustainability-Linked Bond Principles, and by the loan market's equivalent principles. Providers include specialist ESG research firms, credit rating agencies and environmental consultancies with relevant expertise.
What an SPO covers
For a use-of-proceeds framework, such as a green bond framework or social bond framework, the reviewer assesses each of the four core components of the principles:
- Use of proceeds. Whether the eligible categories deliver clear environmental or social benefits and whether exclusions are adequate.
- Project evaluation and selection. How projects are chosen, who decides and how risks are managed.
- Management of proceeds. How funds are tracked, and how unallocated amounts are held.
- Reporting. Whether the issuer commits to allocation and impact reporting of sufficient detail and frequency.
Many opinions also comment on the issuer's overall sustainability strategy, governance and controversies, and map the eligible categories to the Sustainable Development Goals. For a framework for sustainability-linked bonds, the review focuses instead on the relevance and materiality of each KPI, the ambition of each target as explained in the KPI calibration rationale, the bond's financial characteristics and the reporting and verification commitments. The conclusion is usually a statement of alignment, sometimes with a graded assessment of ambition or contribution.
SPOs and other forms of external review
ICMA's guidance on external reviews distinguishes the SPO from several other services. Verification is an independent check against stated criteria, often carried out after issuance on allocation reports or KPI performance, and may take the form of limited or reasonable assurance by an auditor. Certification assesses a bond against an external green standard or label, such as the Climate Bonds Standard, through an approved verifier. Scoring or rating evaluates a bond or framework against a provider's own methodology and gives a score. An SPO is an opinion, not an audit: it does not confirm that proceeds are actually spent as promised. That is the role of post-issuance verification of the post-issuance allocation report and of impact reporting under an impact reporting methodology.
Process and cost
The issuer drafts its framework, often with help from a structuring bank, and shares it with the reviewer together with supporting policies and data. The reviewer interviews management, may suggest changes and then publishes its opinion, usually alongside the framework on the issuer's website. The process often takes a few weeks. Fees are negotiated privately and depend on scope and complexity; they are a small part of total issuance costs for large, repeat issuers but can be significant for smaller or first-time issuers. An SPO is normally refreshed when the framework is materially updated, for example when new eligible categories are added, when the issuer moves from use-of-proceeds bonds to sustainability-linked instruments, or when the underlying principles are revised. Frequent issuers often keep one framework and one opinion in place for several years, issuing many bonds under them, which spreads the cost. Investors generally expect the opinion to be no older than the framework it covers and to be easy to find on the issuer's website.
Regulation and limitations
For most of their history SPO providers were unregulated. Concerns about conflicts of interest, since the issuer pays for the review, about inconsistent methods and about greenwashing brought greater scrutiny. IOSCO published recommendations on ESG ratings and data products providers in 2021, and several jurisdictions have since introduced codes of conduct or rules. In the European Union, the European Green Bond Regulation, adopted in 2023, requires external reviewers of bonds marketed as European Green Bonds to register with ESMA.
Other limitations are that an SPO assesses documents at a point in time, can be positive about frameworks of modest ambition, and uses scales that differ between providers, which makes opinions hard to compare. Investors therefore treat an SPO as one input alongside their own analysis and third-party ESG ratings.
External links
Ref 1180001376