Revaluations and other changes in assets are the entries in the national accounts and government finance statistics that explain why a balance sheet can change even when nobody buys, sells, borrows or lends. Share prices rise, a currency falls, an oil field is discovered, a flood destroys buildings or a loan is written off. None of these is a transaction, but each changes the value of assets, liabilities and net worth.
The family starts with other economic flows, the umbrella term for all such changes. These divide into other changes in the volume of assets and revaluations, which are holding gains and losses caused by price changes. Holding gains can be split again into a neutral part, which just keeps pace with general inflation, and a real part. Finally, gains can be realized or unrealized, although the national accounts record both in the same way. The general concept is covered under holding gain.
Other Economic Flows
Other economic flows are changes in the value or volume of assets and liabilities that do not result from transactions. Together with transactions, they explain the full difference between an opening and a closing balance sheet:
Here OCVA stands for other changes in the volume of assets, and revaluations are holding gains less holding losses. For example, if a pension fund starts the year with bonds worth 500, buys a further 40, writes off 5 after an issuer defaults and gains 15 from rising prices, its closing holding is 500 + 40 − 5 + 15 = 550.
In the SNA these flows are recorded in two accounts that follow the capital and financial accounts in the sequence of accounts: the other changes in the volume of assets account and the revaluation account. Separating them from transactions keeps saving and investment free of price swings while still showing the full movement in wealth.
Other Changes in the Volume of Assets
Other changes in the volume of assets record changes in the quantity of assets and liabilities that are not caused by transactions or by price movements. The 2008 SNA groups them into several types:
- Economic appearance of assets, such as the discovery of mineral reserves or the recognition of a new asset.
- Economic disappearance of non-produced assets, such as the depletion of natural resources.
- Catastrophic losses from earthquakes, floods, wars and similar events.
- Uncompensated seizures, for example confiscation without fair payment.
- Other changes not elsewhere classified, including the write-off of bad debts by a creditor.
- Changes in classification, such as a unit moving between sectors.
A hurricane that destroys a port worth 200 reduces the owner's nonfinancial assets by 200 in this account, without any effect on GDP or on saving. The account explains movements that would otherwise appear as unexplained gaps in balance sheets.
Neutral Holding Gain
A neutral holding gain is the part of a holding gain that just keeps an asset's purchasing power constant, rising in line with the general price level. It is what an asset would have gained if its price had moved exactly with a general measure of inflation:
Here is the value of the asset at the start of the period, and and are the general price index at the start and end. If an asset is worth 1,000 and the general price index rises from 100 to 104, the neutral holding gain is 1,000 × (1.04 − 1) = 40.
The SNA uses a broad index, ideally one covering final expenditure, for this calculation. Neutral holding gains matter because a gain that only matches inflation does not make the holder better off in real terms. Financial assets fixed in money terms, such as deposits, earn no nominal holding gain but still have a neutral gain, so their real holding gain is negative during inflation.
Real Holding Gain
A real holding gain is the change in an asset's value over and above what was needed to keep pace with the general price level. It is the nominal holding gain less the neutral holding gain, and it measures the change in the command of the asset over goods and services in general:
Continuing the example, if the asset worth 1,000 actually rises to 1,060 while general prices rise 4 per cent, the nominal holding gain is 60, the neutral gain 40 and the real gain 60 − 40 = 20. If it had risen only to 1,030, the real holding gain would be −10, a real loss even though its money value increased.
Real holding gains and losses show genuine shifts in wealth between sectors during inflation. In a period of rising prices, lenders holding fixed-value claims suffer real holding losses, while borrowers make matching real gains on their liabilities. This transfer is one of the ways inflation redistributes wealth, and the SNA revaluation account can show it explicitly.
Realized Holding Gain
A realized holding gain is one that has been turned into cash or another asset by selling the asset or settling the liability. An unrealized holding gain, covered under unrealized holding gain, applies to assets still held at the end of the period.
In business accounting and in taxation the distinction matters a great deal: many accounting frameworks report some unrealized gains outside profit, and most tax systems charge capital gains tax only when a gain is realized. The national accounts take a different view. Holding gains accrue continuously as prices change, whether or not the owner sells, and they are recorded in the revaluation account in the period they occur. When an asset is sold, the sale is recorded as a transaction at the current price, and the gain built up until that point has already been recorded. Realized gains are therefore not shown as income in the national accounts, which is one reason national saving differs from business profits.
How the flows compare
| Flow | Caused by | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Transaction | Agreement between units | Purchase of a bond |
| Other change in volume | Events that change quantity | Discovery, disaster, write-off |
| Neutral holding gain | General inflation | Asset value rising with the price level |
| Real holding gain | Relative price change | House prices rising faster than inflation |
Exchange rate effects on foreign-currency assets are also revaluations; in monetary data they appear as other revaluations and foreign exchange revaluation. Asset types are set out under asset classification in the national accounts.
Ref 1100001831