The Renewable Fuel Standard (RFS) is a United States federal program that requires transportation fuel sold in the country to contain a minimum volume of renewable fuels such as ethanol, biodiesel and renewable diesel. It was created by the Energy Policy Act of 2005 and expanded by the Energy Independence and Security Act of 2007, and it is administered by the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), which sets the required volumes and converts them into annual percentage obligations for refiners and importers of gasoline and diesel.
The program works through a tradable credit, the Renewable Identification Number (RIN), so compliance has become a commodity market in its own right. RIN prices feed into refinery margins, pump prices and the economics of biofuel producers, and the program ties energy markets to agricultural commodities such as corn and soybean oil. It is one of several regulatory credit markets, alongside emissions trading and renewable energy certificates, that attach a price to a policy target.
History and legal basis
The 2005 act set the first standard, often called RFS1, which required 7.5 billion gallons of renewable fuel by 2012. The 2007 act replaced it with RFS2, raising the statutory target to 36 billion gallons by 2022, with a growing share to come from advanced and cellulosic biofuels and with conventional fuel, mainly corn-starch ethanol, effectively capped at 15 billion gallons. The 2007 law also introduced lifecycle greenhouse gas thresholds for each fuel category, compared with the gasoline or diesel the fuel replaces.
Actual cellulosic production fell far short of the statute, and the EPA has used its waiver powers to reduce the cellulosic volume and, in some years, the advanced and total volumes. For years after 2022 the statute contains no volume table, so the EPA sets the volumes itself by rulemaking, weighing factors listed in the law such as supply, cost, energy security and environmental effects.
Fuel categories and the nested structure
The RFS sorts fuels into categories, each identified on the RIN by a code:
- Cellulosic biofuel (D3). Fuel made from cellulose, hemicellulose or lignin, such as crop residues, with the deepest required emissions reduction.
- Biomass-based diesel (D4). Biodiesel and renewable diesel made from vegetable oils, animal fats and used cooking oil, used in place of middle distillate fuels.
- Advanced biofuel (D5). Renewable fuel other than corn-starch ethanol that meets the advanced emissions threshold, such as sugarcane ethanol.
- Renewable fuel (D6). The general category, which includes conventional corn ethanol.
The categories are nested. A cellulosic or biomass-based diesel RIN can be used to meet the advanced obligation, and any RIN counts toward the total renewable fuel obligation. Higher-tier RINs are therefore worth at least as much as lower-tier ones, and the spread between D4, D5 and D6 prices shows which part of the mandate is hardest to meet.
How RINs work
Each gallon of qualifying fuel produced or imported generates RINs, recorded in the EPA Moderated Transaction System (EMTS). The number of RINs per gallon is set by an equivalence value based on energy content relative to ethanol: ethanol generates one RIN per gallon, biodiesel usually 1.5 and renewable diesel usually 1.7. RINs stay attached to the fuel until it is blended into gasoline or diesel for US transport use, when the blender separates them and may sell them. Obligated parties, which are refiners and importers of petroleum products, retire separated RINs with the EPA each year to show compliance. RINs carry a vintage year, and a limited share of an obligation may be met with the previous year's RINs, which lets traders bank credits between years.
Calculating the obligation
An obligated party's renewable volume obligation (RVO) for each category is its annual output or imports of gasoline and diesel multiplied by the percentage standard the EPA publishes for that category and year:
Here the percentage standard is the EPA's required renewable share for the category, and the volume is the non-renewable gasoline and diesel the party produced or imported, in gallons. The RVO is expressed in RINs. Take a hypothetical total renewable fuel standard of 11 percent and a refiner that produces 500 million gallons. Its obligation is RINs. If it must buy them all at a hypothetical $0.80 each, the cost is dollars, about 8.8 cents per gallon of fuel it sells.
Market effects and controversies
RIN prices reflect how hard it is to blend the required volumes. The blend wall, the limit on how much ethanol the gasoline pool can absorb when most US gasoline is sold as E10 (10 percent ethanol, see gasoline grades and blendstocks), pushed conventional RIN prices sharply higher in 2013. Merchant refiners without blending operations must buy RINs and argue that the cost squeezes their crack spread; integrated companies and blenders with surplus RINs can sell them. Much of the RIN cost is thought to pass through into fuel prices.
Small refineries, those processing no more than 75,000 barrels of crude oil a day, may petition for exemption on grounds of disproportionate economic hardship, and the number of exemptions granted in some years, and whether the lost volumes were reallocated, led to repeated litigation. The program has also prompted debate about food prices, land use and lifecycle emissions, which became prominent during the 2007–2008 world food price crisis. RINs generated without real fuel production have led to fraud cases, and buyers bear the risk of invalid credits.
External links
Ref 1180002005